THCB

Categories

Above the Fold

Can the physical examination save us from the dehumanization of medicine?

• 7

By ROBERT WACHTER

In last week’s NEJM, physician-author Abraham Verghese paints a disturbing picture
of a medical world in which technology has morphed from tool to object,
the patient relegated to a supporting role. To me, Abraham has nailed
the diagnosis but not the treatment.

I had the distinct pleasure of getting to know Abraham when we both served on the board of the ABIM (actually I came to know his work 15 years earlier, when I reviewed his bestselling book, My Own Country, for the NEJM). Abraham is a romantic and a traditionalist, and in last week’s New England Journal
piece he poignantly lays out a problem he has fretted about for years:
namely, that information technology is dehumanizing the practice of
medicine. Describing rounds with his ward team at Stanford, his new
academic home (he was recently recruited there from the UT-San
Antonio), he recalls:

When I stroked a patient’s
palm and caused a twitch of the mentalis muscle under the chin — the
palmomental reflex — it was as if I were performing magic. Still, the
demands of charting in the electronic medical record (EMR), moving
patients through the system, and respecting work-hour limits led
residents to spend an astonishing amount of time in front of the
monitor; the EMR was their portal to consultative teams, the pharmacy,
the laboratory, and radiology. It was meant to serve them, but at times
the opposite seemed true.

Continue reading…

The Downfall of AIG

By ROBERT LASZEWSKI

Those of you outside of Washington, DC likely missed the Washington Post’s three-part investigation of the events leading to the downfall of AIG.

It makes for good holiday reading. I highly recommend the series to you.

Knowing the culture at AIG from many years of activity with the company and its leadership, I can tell you the story certainly has the culture right.

While this is not a health care story per se, it is a story about risk taking and understanding, and never getting cocky about, risk. AIG
execs argued for years they really had no risk in their credit default
swap business. My experience is that when someone is willing to pay you
lots of money to lay a risk off on you–in this case a whopping $80
billion of exposure–there is risk.

You can read the full report here.

Critical of Critical

• 49

By Matthew Holt

Like legions of other wonks when I discovered that Tom Daschle was going to be Obama’s point guy on health care, I sent off for a copy of his book Critical. It’s a fast and easy read, but in its examination of the problem it doesn’t add much to superior books on what’s wrong with health care (much of the first section reads like an undergrad’s attempt to summarize Jonathan Cohn’s Sick) and there are some pretty weak logic flows and basic editing throughout (he refers to the book Uninsured in America on p155 as though it’s already been introduced before it actually gets introduced on p161). But ignoring all that, what does Daschle suggest we actually do?

First, he promotes himself as a scholar of failed attempts at health reform past, and of course a witness to the most recent attempt.

Continue reading…

Are We Finally Entering the Golden Age of Healthcare Transparency?

By BOB WACHTER, MDRobert_wachter

When will patients start reviewing quality data before choosing their doctors and hospitals? The answer has been “soon” for several years, but “soon” may finally be the right answer. If you doubt it, check out the Commonwealth Fund’s new site, “Why Not The Best?” The central premise of the healthcare transparency movement has been that
putting data on the Web (quality, safety, satisfaction, even cost) will change consumer behavior, the way such data does for autos and restaurants. The movement, which began in earnest with the launch of the HospitalCompare website by Medicare in 2003, lives by the following catechism:

  1. Let’s post some, even rudimentary, quality data on the Web
  2. Patients will look at the data, and demand improvement of their existing providers or choose better ones
  3. This consumerism will create “skin in the game” around performance data
  4. Hospitals and providers, now motivated to improve, will do what it takes to get better.

Continue reading…

Is Massachusetts a model for national reform?

• 18

By Charlie BakerCharlie_baker

I get asked this question a lot these days, which shouldn’t be that surprising.  Harvard Pilgrim is headquartered in Massachusetts, and the Massachusetts health care reform plan is already a couple of years old.  More importantly, it has added about 440,000 people to the insured ranks (185,000 through unsubsidized private plans and another 255,000 through subsidized, Medicaid-like coverage), has maintained high employer participation (over 70%) and doesn’t appear to be crowding out private coverage as public coverage expands.

But my answer to this question remains “it depends.” There were profound differences between Massachusetts and the rest of the country before health care reform took center stage here that make relying on our experience somewhat challenging for the nation as a whole. For example, Massachusetts already had guaranteed-issue requirements for individual health insurance coverage even before reform. Today, most states don’t. So in Massachusetts, individual coverage was available to anyone who wanted to buy it, but it was really, really expensive.

That’s because most of the people who buy individual coverage — absent a mandate to purchase — usually plan to use health care services once they purchase the insurance. Insurance works through risk pooling – a small number of people who get sick spend the premiums paid by a much larger group of people who don’t.  If most of the people who buy the product plan to use it, there’s not enough healthy people to keep the overall price down.Continue reading…

Health and health care in 2009 – a year of managing risks and wild cards

By Jane Sarasohn Kahn

As we inevitably do this time of year, we prognosticate about the new year. This time around, it’s a toughie: there are too many uncertainties that preclude us from doing a straight-line forecast for 2009, especially in health and health care.

Here are some trends and wild cards to keep in mind for 2009: the year of managing risks.

How will the macroeconomy play out against health care in the new year? Keep in mind the Kaiser Family Foundation’s metric on unemployment: an increase of 1% unemployment leads to 1.1 million uninsured, and 1 million more people added to Medicaid. This was the math that worked in 2007-8. The metric will probably change in 2009 as Governors struggle to balance budgets while providing medical services, education, and safe streets to citizens. The National Governors Association, and the individual state heads, have all warned that Governors will inevitably cut services in 2009 and into 2010 if tax receipts continue to decline.

Continue reading…

My Health Care Reform House Party

• 6

By Michael L. Millenson

The Obama-Biden Transition Team has encouraged individuals across the country to gather in small groups with friends and neighbors to discuss their ideas for health care reform. The team provided a background paper, discussion guide and a specific list of questions as a framework within which citizens could provide feedback to health reform czar-designate Tom Daschle. More than a thousand would-be hosts have officially registered on the change.gov website, and my wife and I were recently invited to one such gathering in a small village (yes, that’s the official designation) north of Chicago. My report below is not the official one.

‘Twas three nights before Christmas, and despite cold and stormWe’d gathered together to talk health care reform.Clutching Team Obama’s brief questionnaireWe went over each item with scrupulous care.Middle-class, middle-aged and in the MidwestWith our host’s college kids for reality test.O’er the country many thousands had signed up for the sameDespite fear “special interests” would come rig the game.But as we plain folk gathered by the living room fireWe closely read instructions, then vented our ire.

Continue reading…

“Get Well Soon” Wishes for Health Policy Pioneer Paul Ellwood

• 1

By Michael L. Millenson

Here’s a greeting card conundrum. What exactly do you say to an 82-year old man who, emailing you about a joint project you were working on, notes that he has just survived  “a 12-foot backward fall into a jagged confined space. Result at least 6 smashed cervical and thoracic vertebrae. [But] no paralysis! In a halo and off full duty for a while, but eager to rejoin the hunt.”

“Get well soon” seems so pallid a reply.

Paul Ellwood, who survived this most recent harrowing accident, is best known as the man who originated the term health maintenance organization and then got the federal government to support the concept. He was also one of the first policy thinkers to push vigorously for patient-centered measures of care quality, through his Jackson Hole Group and, since the mid-1990s, on his own.

He’s also one tough hombre.

Continue reading…

Merry Christmas & Happy Hols

• 4

By Matthew Holt

Thanks for reading THCB this year. Thanks to to all the authors who we’ve featured and thanks to John and Sarah for keeping the train on the tracks. And thanks to all who commented and made THCB a great place for educated debate about health care issues.

We’ll be posting a little over the next week with some forecasts for 2009–-which is shaping up to be an interesting year in health policy at least. And there’ll be a new look for THCB early in 2009 too.

But for now enjoy the holiday!

I’m in Tahoe where there was 2 foot of powder last night, which I’ll be heading out to enjoy on my snowboard soon!

assetto corsa mods