THCB

The Trump Healthcare Interview: Part 2

Screen Shot 2016-03-12 at 9.55.09 AMDonald Trump is leading the Republican delegate count and has the best chance of becoming the Republican nominee and, just maybe, even President. In February, we at THCB asked Scottish-Canadian-Californian healthcare futurist Ian Morrison to conduct an interview with Trump, figuring that Morrison would have an in with Trump given Trump’s praise for Scottish and Canadian healthcare. Fittingly, that interview was published on THCB on President’s Day, February 16th. Since then Donald Trump has racked up impressive victories and more importantly has released some specifics of his healthcare proposal. THCB thought it was time for Morrison to reach out to Mr. Trump again–Matthew Holt

MORRISON: Thanks for making time Mr. Trump, it is a pleasure to have a chance to follow up with you.

TRUMP: You were a little rough on me last time, but I enjoyed it, I thought I did very well in the interview.

MORRISON: Indeed you did, it was incredible. Mr. Trump before we get to your healthcare plan, let’s just catch up on the race. Since we last talked you have had some impressive victories in a wide variety of states from Hawaii to Mississippi. Why do you think you have done so well?

TRUMP. I’m winning everywhere, everywhere, and with all the groups: vets, high income, low income (we love the low-income). I won Hispanics in Nevada? Hispanics, Trump? They like me because I am a winner, and I’m winning everywhere. I am winning by a lot.

MORRISON: You did particularly well in the South, the so called SEC primaries, where Ted Cruz was expected to do well, particularly with evangelicals. You won by more than 20 points in Alabama for example.

TRUMP: Well they loved me in South Carolina, I won big there and then I did the dog whistle to the Klan and that probably helped, in the South.

MORRISON: You mean being slow to disavow David Duke and the Klan before those southern primaries?

TRUMP: It worked well, we had hats ready: “Make America White Again” but Corey (Editor’s note–He’s referring to Corey Lewandowski Trump’s Campaign Manager who himself made news recently by manhandling a female reporter) told me it probably wouldn’t work in the General, but we trademarked them anyway, I couldn’t believe it was available, so we may use the “Make America White Again” hats later, we’ll see. But now I disavow, I disavow, how many times do I have to say it.

MORRISON: Mr. Trump are you a racist?

TRUMP: Look I told the New York Times Editorial Board the whole story on deep background. Republican primaries are about getting angry, white people to turn up. Those people are tired and angry at the Mexicans, the Muslims, and Obama (we still don’t know if he was born in Kenya). So when we win, we can be nicer in the general election, because I get along with everyone.

MORRISON: But in the meantime Mr. Trump you have called Mexican immigrants rapists and murderers and only “some of them are nice people”. A set of assertions that are factually incorrect. You plan to deport 11 million undocumented immigrants, separating families, and build a wall to prevent anyone from returning. You also called for a temporary ban on all Muslims coming to the US, regardless of their circumstances or legal immigration status. You stereotyped Jewish people as being “good at making deals”. You have young black demonstrators forcibly thrown out of your rallies, urging supporters to rough them up. And you criticized the Pope for being too political. All of this sounds like you are a xenophobic, racist, bigot with fascist tendencies.

TRUMP: Maybe that’s why I am winning……. Look I love immigrants. I married two of them. But they came here……legally.

MORRISON: Did Melania come on an H1B Visa like the ones you are trying to eliminate?

TRUMP: She’s a supermodel. They have special visas for supermodels and world class golfers. Look Adam Scott just won my tournament at Trump Doral, he’s Australian, he can come in. Rory from Ireland, in, no problem. Supermodels, in, no problem, but they have to be a 10.

MORRISON: Mitt Romney criticized you in a remarkable speech in Utah two weeks ago, basically arguing that you were unfit to be president; you weren’t much of a businessman; and that the party should vote for Rubio in Florida, Kasich in Ohio, denying you the delegates and leading to a contested convention in which anyone, maybe even Romney, might win. So far that strategy seemed to have backfired on the Republican establishment with your victories this week. How do you see it?

TRUMP: Romney choked. He’s a stiff who should have beaten Obama. He begged me for his endorsement in 2012: he would have gone down on his knees to get it, and now he turns on me? But we won easily this week in a lot of states, and we had a great event in Jupiter with the Trump steaks, and the Trump water, and the Trump wine, and the Trump winning. So Romney is a loser. I have a store worth more than Romney.

MORRISON: What about Rubio and Kasich.

TRUMP: We will win Florida. Bye-Bye Little Marco.

MORRISON: Why so much animosity towards Senator Rubio?

TRUMP: He hit me with the hands thing. He said I had little hands…and you know, the implication. But, I’m a counter puncher, so I had to come back with the schlong at the debate. I guarantee you there is no problem. That I can assure you. I would have pulled it out at the debate, but Melania told me to be presidential.

MORRISON: And Kasich?

TRUMP: We win Ohio and Kasich goes bye-bye. Then it’s me and Lyin’ Ted–I can’t wait.

MORRISON: You match up well against Senator Cruz?

TRUMP: Look Cruz is not likeable. He has no friends. And he has a problem with the Goldman Sachs and Citi loans, so we will beat Ted. We will win all the big ones: New York, New Jersey, California and we will wrap it all up by the Convention and then we can go after Hillary or Bernie. It might be Bernie, because Hillary may get indicted and Bernie is winning so we may end up against Bernie. We’ll see. Either way we win easily. Bernie is a socialist Jew from New York who has never had a real job. I am a very successful businessman. I have built a terrific business. I employ tens of thousands of people. I’m a very good Christian (remember 2 Corinthians and the crackers). And, you know, they’re chipping away at Christianity. We’re not going to let that happen anymore..So you put me, a Christian businessman up against a Jewish socialist. Who do you think will win?

MORRISON: Which brings me to healthcare. You recently released some specifics about your health plan. Let me quote a respected conservative health care commentator Avik Roy who wrote in Forbes magazine about your plan: “It has the look and feel of something that a 22-year-old congressional staffer would write for a back-bencher based on a cursory review of Wikipedia.” Mr. Trump, a lot of pundits from the right and left have criticized your 7 point plan as a hackneyed rehash of old Republican ideas, none of which would work. I thought Trump healthcare was going to be amazing?

TRUMP: I told you last time. We will repeal and replace Obamacare and it will be amazing.

MORRISON: But the 7 point plan didn’t seem very amazing, or new; do you want to talk about it and explain how exactly it would be amazing.

TRUMP: Look this is simply a place to start the negotiation. I told you already, it will be different when I win I am President. I get along with people and I will make a great deal on healthcare.

MORRISON: So you are not a real conservative?

TRUMP: Look I am a conservative, I like to conserve, I just don’t believe in free trade, and I like Planned Parenthood. But with the health plan we start with the conservative ideas and then we will negotiate.

MORRISON: You want to keep guaranteed issuance and in earlier interviews supported the individual mandate.

TRUMP: I disavow the mandate, I disavow. But I want to keep the pre-existing conditions. I told you I don’t want people dying in the streets. And the Trump healthcare plan will do all that.

MORRISON: So what are the specifics?

TRUMP: First, we get rid of the lines around the states. Once we get rid of the lines then there will be more competition and the prices will fall so fast.

MORRISON: Most healthcare analysts agree that this is impractical to implement given that health insurance is regulated at the state level.

TRUMP: Once the lines are down, the prices will drop I guarantee there isn’t a problem..

MORRISON: Just like your….

TRUMP: Exactly.

MORRISON: The second point in your plan is making health insurance tax deductible for everyone. But only half of people pay income tax, and anyone who is self-employed or has employment-based insurance already has the benefit of tax deductibility, so it is just a tiny sliver of the population who would benefit.

TRUMP: But it sounds good, to say everyone gets a tax break. That’s why we are winning because we say things that sound good to the Trump voter, even if they won’t make much difference.

MORRISON: Your next point is Health Savings Accounts.

TRUMP: It was really Ben’s idea, but I liked but. I like Ben. He is a doctor, so you have to listen to him about this stuff so we will do the Health Savings Account thing.

MORRISON: But Health Savings Accounts have been around as described in your plan since 2003. Ben Carson didn’t invent them. 20 million Americans already have them, how is this a new idea? How is this amazing?

TRUMP: Trump Health Savings Accounts would be a much better brand. People would sign up in droves. We would have hats.

MORRISON: You want to have increased price transparency for doctors, hospitals, and drugs and many people support that. But again it is not a new idea and many groups and organizations from the Obama administration to industry leaders are already promoting this so how is this amazing?

TRUMP: The difference is we will get it done. We will get them all around the table and get it done.

MORRISON: You are in favor of block grants to the states for Medicaid, but you and many other conservatives want to eliminate the lines around the states for regulation of health insurance. Which is it? Should states have more authority or not?

TRUMP: States should have more authority apart from the lines …we need to get rid of the lines.

MORRISON: You also plan on saving healthcare dollars currently spent on illegal immigrants–some $11 billion you estimate. Will that money be used to pay for the wall?

TRUMP: No, the Mexican government will pay for the wall, I can assure you, because of the trade deficit. We have so much leverage with them on trade, and the Mexicans are bringing drugs into the country especially to New Hampshire where it is the number one problem. I couldn’t believe the beautiful hills, and roads and the little towns and the nice people and the number one problem is heroin from Mexico. So we will build a wall and stop it.

MORRISON: Which brings me to a final point of your plan which is to increase free trade on pharmaceuticals and allow importation from other countries where pharmaceutical prices are much lower, like Mexico. Don’t you think that is somewhat ironic, given what you just said?

TRUMP: No, we would bring in the drugs legally. Like oxy. And the prices would come down for oxy so no one would have to buy heroin from the Mexicans.

MORRISON: While we are on pharmaceuticals, earlier in the race you claimed you will save $300 billion on the drugs spend for Medicare recipients, which is remarkable given that the total spend by Medicare on drugs is about $75 billion. How could that possibly work?

TRUMP: Carl.

MORRISON: Excuse me?

TRUMP: Carl Icahn. He is a good friend, a terrific businessman and a fantastic negotiator. He is tough. So I am going to get Carl to lead the negotiation with China on trade. But I will also ask him to negotiate with the drug companies for the drugs for Medicare.

MORRISON: But what if pharmaceutical companies don’t want to reduce prices given they have strong patent protection and monopoly pricing power.

TRUMP: Maybe we will use eminent domain. We’ll see.

MORRISON: What if that is rejected by the courts, what could you do to get drug companies to comply?

TRUMP: Waterboarding….and more.

MORRISON: Mr. Trump that truly is amazing. Thank you.

Editor’s note. As if you needed reminding. This interview is fake. But Donald Trump is real. And his support is growing.

Ian Morrison is health care futurist and former President of the Institute for the Future

Livongo’s Post Ad Banner 728*90

Categories: THCB, Trump

Tagged as: , ,

7
Leave a Reply

4 Comment threads
3 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
5 Comment authors
John IrvineMatthew HoltRogueRadanishkokaBobbyGvegas Recent comment authors
newest oldest most voted
John Irvine
Member

I think this oversimplifies a complex story. I am very, very close to calling this one for Trump. Everything will hinge on the Sanders / Clinton contest. If they had any sense (and I’m not sure they do) they’d team up and form an unholy alliance (Clinton-Sanders is the only practical option) and try to outlast the shitpocalypse that is headed directly at them … A couple of myths here: Myth 1: The Trump phenomenon is about racism. It is about populism. Populism by definition elevates people and views the intelligentsia finds appalling and stupid. Democracies unfortunately don’t always play… Read more »

BobbyGvegas
Member

Clinton-Sanders ticket, I totally agree. Bernie could essentially stay in the Senate, where he knows the ropes. They would cover the spectrum from center-right to populist left. It would be a GOP wipeout.

Dana Milbank at WaPo recently made the case for Clinton-Warren. I Bought http://www.HillaryClintonElizabethWarren2016.com a few years back (just squatting the URL), LOL. I could make some cash there.

RogueRad
Member

Agree with you, mostly, but especially that it’s careless dismissing Trump’s supporters as stupid or racist. What their support tells me is that they feel disenfranchised. America is a country built on hope. You can’t have a sizeable portion of the electorate, of whatever colour or stripe, feeling hopeless.

RogueRad
Member

Funny piece, but I agree with Anish that we should not fall in the “Trump proposed this so it must be crap” trap for healthcare. Are HSAs really worse idea than EHRs, or PQRS, or MIPS?

anishkoka
Member

Should bear mentioning that Avik Roy is or recently was involved in the Rubio campaign. Read his tweets…even he’d agree he’s not an objective voice. There’s nothing too wrong with 7 points , except that there are only 7 points. More like a conversation starter than a health care plan. I think it’s simplistic to attribute trumps support to racist/xenophobic thought. In between the clickbait that emerges from his mouth is a strident promise to protect the worker from policies made for the last 20 years that have meant a stagnation in wages for the lower middle class. He upsets… Read more »

BobbyGvegas
Member