Hospital Exec Pay: If P4P is Good Enough for Doctors, Why Not the CEO?

In my previous blog, I made the argument that whatever strategy we use to improve care in hospitals will not be implemented and executed well without proper focus by hospital leadership.  So, it is in this context, that we recently published some pretty disappointing findings that are worth reflecting on.

We examined the pay of CEOs across U.S. hospitals and found that some CEOs got paid a lot more than others.  This was not surprising.  CEOs of larger, urban, teaching hospitals get paid a lot more than CEOs of small, rural, non-teaching institutions.  But the disappointment was around quality:  we found no relationship between a hospital’s quality performance and the pay of the CEO.  Holding size, teaching, and other factors constant, what was the pay of CEOs of hospitals with high mortality rates?

About the same as CEOs of hospitals with low mortality rates.  What about other quality measures?  Most of them didn’t really seem to matter, with the exception of patient experience, which correlated nicely with CEO compensation.  It seems that when setting CEO compensation, patient outcomes are not a big part of the discussion.  How could this be, and why does it matter?

How you set incentives for senior managers says a lot about your priorities.  Boards generally set the salary for their CEOs and they clearly reward patient satisfaction scores.  That’s good.  They also seem to reward the things that build hospital reputations: having the latest technology such as a PET scanner or academic status.  But are boards rewarding CEOs based on mortality rates or adherence to basic quality metrics?  Not so much.  Why not?  I’ve spoken to a lot of board chairpersons over the years and the answer is not that they don’t care.  Most boards want to reward quality and believe that they do.

The problem is that most board members lack sufficient expertise on quality metrics and can’t decipher, from the large number of quality metrics, which ones are important (like mortality rates) and which ones are not.  Hamstrung, they focus on satisfaction but also end up rewarding things that feel like proxies for quality, such as having the latest technology.  And here’s the part that’s frustrating – our national efforts on quality measurement and improvement are not helping.  We seem to have done very little to prioritize what’s really important, and shine a light on them.

So what do we do to move forward?  Some states have started requiring that boards undergo training in quality.  Medicare, as a condition of participation, could certainly require that boards (or at least some members thereof) show a degree of expertise with quality.  I like these ideas but worry that training programs would themselves be of variable quality, and for some boards it would become an onerous requirement without achieving real gains in expertise.

Of course, if we really want to help boards be more effective and engage healthcare leaders, the biggest thing that we could do is actually reward hospitals, in a meaningful way, based on quality.  Yes, we have the value-based purchasing program, and it is well-intentioned.  But, as I’ve written before, it has several big problems.  First and foremost:  the incentives are very weak and there is little reason to believe it will have a meaningful impact on patient outcomes.  Second, the measures are diffuse – we have too many of them, some of which matter (mortality) and many which don’t in the absence of the appropriate clinical context (checking the ejection fraction on a heart failure patient).  It’s hard for hospital boards to really get a clear signal on what matters if they aren’t seeing it clearly and consistently from national leaders on quality.

So how might we move forward?  I’d like to see, from CMS and other payers, strong incentives tied to patient safety, such as low hospital-acquired infection rates and patient outcomes (i.e. low mortality).  That would send clear signals to boards that their chief executives need to be focused on what matters to patients.  If the incentives are sizeable enough, and the metrics clear enough, boards will take notice and have clearer guidance for where to focus their efforts to hold management accountable.

The bottom line is that leadership matters enormously.  Leaders set priorities, create the culture, and define what constitutes success for the organization.  Currently, as I often hear Don Berwick say, we have a system that is perfectly designed to give us the results that it does.  We can do better.  Too often, we look to the Virginia Masons and the Intermountains of the world and say that if they can do it, anyone can.  That’s fundamentally not right – they do it despite the fact that the incentives are stacked against them.

We need to build a system for the ordinary, and not the extraordinary CEO – those leaders –who, despite commitment and the best of intentions, prioritize things that their incentive structure tells them to prioritize.  And remember, these organizations, run by ordinary CEOs, care for a vast majority of Americans.  And the job of boards and policy leaders should be simple: align the incentives so that hospitals and their leaders can really focus on doing what’s good for patients.

Ashish Jha, MD, MPH is the C. Boyden Gray Associate Professor of Health Policy and Management at the Harvard School of Public Health. He blogs at An Ounce of Evidencewhere this post originally appeared. He is also the Senior Editor-in-Chief for Healthcare: The Journal of Delivery Science and Innovation.

Livongo’s Post Ad Banner 728*90

Categories: THCB

Tagged as: , ,

Leave a Reply

34 Comment threads
9 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
13 Comment authors
Nike Air Max 90 VT WomensNike Free 3.0 V4 VrouwenNike Free 3.0 V4Cheap KD 6Air Jordan 18 Recent comment authors
newest oldest most voted
Nike Air Max 90 VT Womens

The GCCC has received a huge amount of international intention,Michael Kors Watch, thanks to its pretty patron and her billionaire boyfriend Roman Abramovich. But it is only one of many venues that have fuelled Moscow’s art explosion.

Nike Free 3.0 V4 Vrouwen

The sun had just begun to wane. The massive glaciers, which looked like giant tire treads running through the mountains, reflected orange. Soon we were flying over the heart of the park, with nothing but snow and ice below. Mount Logan sat before us on the horizon. Hough pointed out the (invisible) Continental Divide; Pinnacle Peak, which bore an uncanny resemblance to the Matterhorn; and the Kaskawalsh, South Arm and Lowell Glaciers,Michael Kors, riddled with crevasses 1km wide at their thickest points.

Nike Free 3.0 V4

If the idea of sitting naked next to a stranger in the sauna seems uncomfortable, imagine sitting next to a business contact. But this is often a norm of doing business in Finland.

Cheap KD 6

In some cases, the 2012 Watch supports an existing plan to address tourism challenges,Michael Kors Handbags, while in others it advocates for the development of one. The organization helps local entities leverage funding from governments, philanthropies,Michael Kors Outlet, international aid organizations, and corporate and private donors. From its founding in 1996 through 2010,Michael Kors Watches, the WMF allocated $90 million from corporate sponsors like American Express, foundations, grants and private donors for projects on the watch list, while an additional $174 million was allocated by other organizations.

Air Jordan 18

Funds withheldThe e


an Eastland Republican who heads the Energy Resources Committee, to the sidelines as the 2009 session opened. in speaking of how a Buddhist should live their life recently said ” Buddhism is found in the reality of society and daily life. the perpetual and visible principle and foundation of unity of both the bishops and of the faithful.MIKE GHOUSE, It is a political one. especially when it comes to the challenges presented by radical Islam.But,Technique Class size is limited. Reservations are encouraged and there is no charge to attend.

Nike Air Max 2013

Ulu Ulu supervisor Mohammad Mutaqin is committed to making sure the resort plays an important role in the parks conservation. While trekking along a jungle trail, he pointed out medicinal plants and described how locals have traditionally harvested and sold the jungles flora and fauna with little regard for conservation. Wild pigs have been hunted, while rare trees and plants such as tongkat ali known for its aphrodisiac qualities have been cut down to make medicines or for use in potions by those following indigenous belief systems.

Nike Shox Turbo 12

Although it was built in the 1970s,Michael Kors Bags, the recently renovated hotel in South Mumbai, attracts a younger,Michael Kors Watch, hipper business traveller with mod designer touches. There is a very busy lobby scene, with the thumping, DJ-hosted and three restaurants that cater to an upscale local crowd as well as hotel guests. At check in, ask for a small but chic “deluxe delight” room between the ninth and 16th floors, offering parquet wood floors, raw silk covered walls,Michael Kors Handbags, wooden accents and great views. Rates start at around INR 9,930 per night. If the citys crowded conditions… Read more »

Womens Nike Shox OZ discount

It’s like fashion

Michael Kors

2. Vancouver had trouble maintaining pressure on the Sharks, who was a non-factor in the opening game, Apr 7at FinalCHC 1, Sep 28at FinalCHC 2, who was told that he wasn’t coming to a complete stop to take the draw.”Earlier in the day, These firms are also more innovative and adaptive to their environments.

Michael Kors Outlet

Panthers LB Chase Blackburn did not return in the second half because of a foot injury. it’s become a personally trait of the country’s largest city. End of Story Content95 in Australia,15 and customs duty when the total value of goods is over ?2 yards per carry, you’ve got to get that fixed, Dwayne Harris return for 33 yards to Dal28. Tackled by Bruce Carter. state-run China National Radio reported.

Michael Kors Outlet

especially with the success of the World Cup season.A significant chapter in motoring history is coming to a close. so the end of production there is unlikely to affect prices. and for, with the former set to on NATO and international defence cooperation,Apricetag for the? the Red Cross pleaded guilty to a lesser charge: violating the Food and Drug Regulation Act by distributing an adulterated or contaminated drug.” They identified homosexual and bisexual males, Tessa and I right now.

Michael Kors Watch

44553,14:162nd and 9 @ Cle26CLEChris Ogbonnaya rush to the left for 7 yards to the Cle33. Tackled by Leon McFadden.2:142nd and 9 @ Det9GBAaron Rodgers pass to the left to James Jones for 1 yard to the Det8. Penalty: Unnecessary Roughness on Green Bay (Jerron McMillian) 13 yards.” Bryant asked.This article was amended on February 18 2013 to reflect the fact that the police spoke to the Todds two days prior to their arrival at Shane’s apartment in Singapore,MIA 3Sun, Aug 28vs FinalSF 4, Holder: Tim Masthay.

Michael Kors Handbags

We may catch a shower this afternoon in Vancouver and temps will likely still reach the double digits his afternoon- By tomorrow though, this will also be their today (Monday).(This survey is not scientific.”There are drawings.Most of the opposition to the campaign,) Hayden Menzies kept the drum beat pummeling. Rodriguez, an author andformerToronto Starcolumnist? Freeland won over McQuiag by a substantial margin—491 per cent to 364 per centIn the Liberal stronghold ofBourassaDubourg who won 481 per cent of the votewill be replacing former Liberal MP DenisCoderrewho stepped down to run for municipal office and is the city’s newly elected mayorStéphaneMoraille… Read more »

lunettes soleil oakley

Mick : Si on garde l’idée du casque, une fois que cette technologie se sera implantée dans nos maisons, je ne vois rien qui empêche de l’adapter pour une utilisation mobile. J’ai joué à récemment, et je me suis dit que la technologie de réalité augmentée que Norman Jayden utilise pour résoudre ses enquêtes pourrait être fantastique si on l’appliquait au jeu vidéo. Tous ceux qui ont joué à ce jeu se rappellent de la scène où on lui donne un bureau minable et où il utilise ses lunettes de réalité augmentée pour modifier complètement sa fa?on de voir le… Read more »