OP-ED

Evidence That Health Does Not Equal Healthcare? Early Results From the Oregon Experiment Are In

The most important study in American health policy in decades, the Oregon Health Insurance Experiment, published two-year results Wednesday in the New England Journal of Medicine. If you’re reading up on the topic, get ready for bombastic claims and scorching heat as opposed to illuminating light. The quick read leads to an easy Drudge headline – “MEDICAID DOESN’T MAKE PEOPLE HEALTHIER: OBAMACARE WILL FAIL!” – but a fuller reading of the evidence provides a more optimistic, and honest, take.

In 2008, Oregon had 90,000 individuals who wanted to enroll in its Medicaid program, but the funding to enroll only a fraction. So it decided to use the opportunity to create an unparalleled experiment: the first Randomized Controlled Trial (RCT) – the gold standard research methodology that is able to isolate the causal effect of an intervention – in Medicaid history. It endeavored to show nothing less than the actual, causal effect that Medicaid has on its population, a first in the field.

This study, in other words, is a big, big deal.

Two years of data are in, and the results are mixed. First up, the disappointing: Medicaid coverage.

“…had no significant effect on the prevalence or diagnosis of hypertension or high cholesterol levels or on the use of medication for these conditions. It increased the probability of a diagnosis of diabetes and the use of medication for diabetes, but it had no significant effect on the prevalence of measured glycated hemoglobin levels of 6.5% or higher.”

The prevalence of high blood pressure and high cholesterol levels weren’t significantly affected by Medicaid coverage, nor was the use of medication to treat them. Even more surprising, increased diagnosis and treatment of diabetes didn’t affect how well enrollees were managing their disease. That is quite surprising, and butts up against our intuition, which holds that diagnosis and treatment of a disease should lead to better control of that disease.

But these figures should be taken in context: because the sample sizes for the above conditions were relatively small, statistically significant outcomes look more disappointing than actual outcomes. For example, the prevalence of hypertension decreased by 7.16% in the Medicaid covered population – a “[change] that would be considered clinically significant.” A larger study population could have shown this finding to be statistically significant, too.

In addition, the study unearthed a number of encouraging findings. Compared to the control population, Medicaid enrollees were 30% less likely to self-report depression; more likely to utilize health care services, including using more prescription drugs, making more visits to the clinic, and having more cholesterol-level screenings done (which increased by almost 50%); and more likely to report higher levels of self-judged health.

(chart from The Oregon Health Insurance Experiment website, via Austin Frakt)

Just as important, being enrolled in Medicaid had a substantial effect on catastrophic medical expenses and medical financial hardship. According to the study, “Catastrophic expenditures, defined as out-of-pocket medical expenses exceeding 30% of income, were nearly eliminated” (emphasis mine). The percent of people who borrowed money to pay bills or skipped payment fell precipitously, by 58%, and the percent of people with any medical debt dropped by 23%. In other words, health insurance is doing what it is supposed to do – protect the consumer from out-of-control, unanticipated medical bills.

That’s a pretty compelling case for Medicaid expansion: less depression, more access to physicians and pharmaceuticals, and a near-elimination of catastrophic, life-changing medical expenditures.

And, as Annie Lowery astutely points out, there’s a lot that this study doesn’t tell us. With only two years of data in, it’s difficult to say what effect Medicaid coverage will have in ten years, or twenty; one could argue that many of the health measures will take more than two years to stabilize, or that the reduced financial strain may lead to long-term reductions in stress levels, which could have an effect on hypertension and heart disease.

Where all of this leaves you probably depends on where you stood before. If you believed Medicaid doesn’t make beneficiaries better off, your evidence for that can (arguably) be found in this study; if you believed that Medicaid leaves beneficiaries better off, you can make that case, too.

But whatever you’re inclined to believe, the truth seems to be somewhere in the middle. Health insurance can only do so much; as Aaron Carroll and Austin Frakt point out at the Incidental Economist, it’s “necessary, but not sufficient to improve health” – one piece of a much-larger puzzle. If nothing else, this study should illuminate the need for better health coverage, not just more; merely having the insurance isn’t enough if it’s not paired with the right type of intervention. Health policy researchers, policy wonks, innovators, and practitioners should work together to create a product /service that takes coverage a step further and, for instance, leads to sustained and marked improvements in diabetes control.

For now, we’re stuck with a bit of ambiguity, along with brash headlines, condemnations of government intervention, and pundits discussing What This Means for Obamacare. This argument won’t be settled today, tomorrow, or next week, so buckle in for the ride.

Mike Miesen is a healthcare consultant and recent graduate of the University of Wisconsin-Madison. He is currently on loan to the Ugandan Ministry of Health (via NGO), leading a project to reduce maternal mortality. You can follow him on Twitter @MikeMiesen.

Livongo’s Post Ad Banner 728*90

17
Leave a Reply

17 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
13 Comment authors
fisticuffs slotAdult Shop Dealgooglechubbyfuzz1012.blog.fc2.comSofia Recent comment authors
newest oldest most voted
fisticuffs slot
Guest

Two symbols pay out $4, three symbols pay out $60, four
symbols pay out $1,200, and all five Chain Mail
symbols pay out $6,000. org offers so many links to
online casinos that you can find a game where you can play at stake levels you can afford.
Couple this with the stable gaming platform and the casinos history
and you got yourself a first class online casino.

Adult Shop Deal
Guest

I just like the helpful information you provide in your articles.
I’ll bookmark your blog and test again here regularly.
I am fairly sure I’ll be informed plenty of new stuff right here!
Good luck for the next!

google
Guest

Hello, yeah this piece of writing is in fact fastidious and I have
learned lot of things from it on the topic of blogging.
thanks.

My web blog google

chubbyfuzz1012.blog.fc2.com
Guest

You have some interesting info here, well written as well as your website is user-friendly.

Sofia
Guest

Ability is rapidly expanding and evolving, will provide real money.
Heaven Or hell 2 GamesDescripciones :Battle against the computer and video games.
If you can be enjoyed within the Southern Hemisphere anime rpg too.
Using the manner anime rpg the economy. Sheldon is a cow, anime rpg steer, horse, and this participation adds to the game
is aimed at helping kids to use your intellectual mind. If
a player trying to improvise in your gaming needs.

download games
Guest

Games can feel at KingsIsle, creators space mmo of the older technology preceding it.
Having 5 parties wanting to know new people and
play against opponents space mmo who are noble, patient and slow to start making money.
Moreover its free games online are intense about their particular feelings plus intellectual skills observed upon what exactly would the best choices out there.
Just looking at those favorite moments and organized corporate group operations.

love it
Guest

Outstanding quest there. What occurred after? Thanks!

Take a look at my weblog: love it

moncler prix
Guest

Fonde en 1952, Moncler, originaire de la France dans une petite ville, doudoune moncler 2013 plus tard clbre pour le ski alpinisme doudoune, maintenant entre la marque mondiale de luxe un dredon de plumes. Juin 2011, Moncler essay annonce, mais alors les fonds de private equity France Eurazeo acquis 45 % de ses actions, le prix est indiqu raisonnable, alors que la crise de la dette europenne ne fait que commencer, Italie march est instable et donc Moncler shelve plans d’introduction en bourse.Ruffini plus tt a dclar aux journalistes, numrant les besoins attentif examen avec d’autres partenaires d’quit trois, actuellement… Read more »

vrai moncler
Guest

logo sur ses produits pour l’arme et a continu les produire avec des sacs de couchage et sacs dos. Aprs la guerre, Bauer a galement commenc vendre des vtements pour femmes et, en 1949, a t employant 125 couturires suivre la demande.Bien que le nylon avait t dcouvert et tait produit commercialement depuis 1939, il avait t trop forte demande pendant la guerre pour des articles tels que des parachutes, des pneus et des cordes de la tente d’avoir beaucoup surplus pour une utilisation dans les vtements. Dans les premires annes d’aprs-guerre, le premier vol de nylon Moncler a t… Read more »

moncler lille
Guest

Moncler , Moncler Vestes et au Royaume – Uni , Manteaux Moncler SONT les Mieux inond et accepteur non acceptabilit acceptable . Pas Moncler le Seul pouvait l’action Qué Vous la responsable de la base ,Ce pas n’est juste Assez douce , Bien Que Tous Deux also la soumission et Qui est facile à transporter . Remerciements Connecté Avec Moncler à long pardessus manteaux de PEU intérêt des Nations Unies ainsi que Et Vous n’avez généralement polo dire oui à Devenir non passionné reconna millésime Eventuellement Être propre. Vous pourriez Être Entreprise sur le doux anorak versez obtenir la congélation… Read more »

moncler gamme bleu
Guest

Habituellement, les producteurs semblent finir par jeter concurrents qui comprend une histoire criminelle de Moncler menf le spectacle, mais un long chemin qu’ils havent cette période autour . Nous n’avons pas eu beaucoup de Moncler vestes de temps pour magasiner cette semaine lors de l’utilisation des deux regards si Heejun n’ont aucune idée de ce qui repassait dans le magasin pour lui ou elle. J’ai eu ce bon aperçu de Neiman Marcus et Guess. J’ai adoré cette conception de fleur sur sa veste moncler mens . nous pouvons toujours regarder dans la syndication . Grand spectacle . beaucoup plus à… Read more »

moncler t shirt
Guest

Alors, comment pouvez-vous trouver la conduite de la sant sans amendes d’assurance qui est la baisse des primes de sorte que vous pouvez vous permettre de payer Vous pouvez souscrire une assurance qui offre jusqu’ tant sur le montant total de l’excdent ou il pourrait mme couvrir tout cela. En tant que propritaire d’entreprise, moncler, vous devez tre. Faites le bon choix et vous pouvez mme vous retrouver avec un meilleur plan de la sant que par le pass! Gardez la commercialisation de ces perspectives et vos proches ratios augmenteront considrablement.Plus de prvention: Certains groupes de personnes ages, moncler vente,… Read more »

woolrich bologna
Guest

Letteratura per noi di aprire una finestra , la finestra Journey Into Amazing Caves ! Letteratura è uno spirito dei tempi e lo scopritore di shaper .

kerry pay
Guest
kerry pay

Health insurance helps but I have had Medicare & Medicaid since my surgeon messed up my back surgery and damaged a nerve in my leg which caused my now social security disability thus Medicaid because I was unable to return to work because of the damage he did in surgery. My surgery was to have been 4 hours but became 8 and massive complications that no one reported in medical records but for some reason something he put in those records that were only sent to government and not anyone else I received disabilty . He probaly knew he messed… Read more »

pune hospital
Guest

Very well said Health insurance can only do so much for healthcare but it doesn’t help your health.