Comparing Biden’s health reform plan to Obama’s

It’s the time in the political season to make way too much of the impact a vice president can have on the presidential contest.

So I hope you don’t mind if I extend that amusing parlor sport into the arena of health care reform and consider how how Joe Biden’s original proposal for health care reform compares to Barack Obama’s.

If nothing else, it’s a good way to parse a few of the issues likely to be magnified when Obama and McCain yammer back and forth about their health care plans in the coming weeks.

Biden’s plan, unloosed on the public in October 2007 to support his presidential run, isn’t that different from Obama’s.

ObamaBoth cover the usual list of Democrat health care touchpoints — making
coverage affordable with subsidies to people and businesses, creating
new public options to supplement private offerings, preventing insurers
from denying coverage to the sick, emphasizing prevention and chronic
disease treatment, etc., etc., etc., yada yada and so forth.

Neither plan, significantly, follows the Hillary Clinton proposal for
mandating coverage for all people. Neither does the vaporous plank on
health care in the Democrat’s party platform draft.

[Note: It’s a bit tough to find information on Biden’s plan at this
point in history. The former presidential campaign website is now redirected to a page on Obama’s site
announcing Biden as VP, effectively airbrushing evidence of the Biden
plan from the current debate. We can expect the same from Mittromney.com any day now.]

The key distinctions between the Obama and Biden proposals:

: Obama requires all kids to have insurance. Biden doesn’t require anybody to be insured.

Like Obama, Biden would use a mix of subsidies, tax breaks
and expanded  options to help people buy into either private or public
plans not unlike the one enjoyed by federal employees. Unlike Obama,
Biden would give adults 55-64 the option of buying into Medicare, again
with subsidies as needed.

Insurance regulation:
Obama would prohibit insurers from denying
coverage based on pre-existing conditions. Biden would provide
incentives to discourage insurers from doing so.

Drug prices:
Obama favors changing laws to permit federal price
negotiation with drug makers over the cost of drugs for Medicare,
reimportation of drugs from other countries, and supporting development
of generic drugs. Biden mentions only allowing bargaining for Medicare
drug prices.

Health Tech
: Both support investments in health information technology
in order to make care stronger, safer and better looking. Obama wants
to spend $10 billion over 5 years, then make use of certain tech
mandatory. Biden wants to spend $1 billion per year.

Total estimated costs:
Such estimates are fictional, of course, if not
delusional. But Biden costed out his plan at $120 billion per year.
Obama, that tightwad, estimates outlays of $60 to $65 million per year.
Obama says he’ll pay for it by rolling back Bush’s tax cuts for people
making over $250,000 per year. Biden didn’t say how he’d pay the bill.

To the extent this bean-hill of wonkery amounts to much, the public
will never hear about it, of course. One of the easiest predictions on
health care politics over the next many weeks is this:

McCain’s plan will be portrayed as an industry-friendly,
lobbyist-shaped non-reform that leaves millions of people uncovered,
undercovered and suffering while the rich and the lucky who own seven
houses (they think) enjoy gold-plated, platinum-priced coverage.

Obama’s will be dismissed as an act of tax-and-spend FDR-era
extravagance that will create a huge new bureaucracy, drive god-fearing
businesses out of health care entirely, suck the working class dry and
lead the country down that slippery slope toward Stalinistic central

But back to reality. This is easy to predict too:

Any eventual reform to health care, regardless of who wins, is going to
become the usual mess based first on ideological inclination and then
processed through the machine of money, industry influence, political
pandering and either "compromise" or "cooperation," depending on how
one views unwillingness to demand absolutes.
And this will occur no matter who the vice president is.

5 replies »

  1. As you may all know 8 Ball Pool by Miniclip is the
    largest and very best multiplayer Pool match on-line! It gives you the capability to perform for free
    against other opponents. It really is hard to get cash when you don’t have the eight Ball ultimate device four.3 this is why you will want this instrument to demonstrate off in the multiplayer tournaments
    and can brag with the 8 ball supreme hack 4.three you have been able to purchase all types of
    cues and table pores and skin. With this 8 Ball multiplayer
    cheat you able to enter the pool shop and purchasing anything
    at all to customize your profile to your eyes. With two clicks
    you will have Free of charge Miniclip Credits, Endless Cost-free eight Ball Multiplayer Pool Points, Cost-free 8 Ball Multiplayer Awards and
    previous but not least Cost-free 8 Ball Pool Multiplayer Accuracy Hack.
    You will virtually constantly car-get your 8ball online
    games. With the 8 Ball Pool Greatest Hack four.three,
    You will no for a longer time have to devote your
    entire working day attempting to make all achievements or waste your useful funds
    on pool cues, tables or boosts! This 8 Ball Multiplayer Hack will conserve you treasured time by obtaining all what you want
    in a single click, You will be ready to alter volume of coins you desire
    far. It gives numerous attributes that no other equipment will supply.
    What are you waiting for? Make the most of eight
    Ball Pool Multiplayer!

  2. My grandaughter came to me and said Nana would you please vote for Mr.Oboma for me,I ask her why she said he is like me, he will make a change make things better and you said Joe Biden looks out for old people,someone for you and someone for me she’s 9yrs I’m 53.I live in Delaware Joe might talk alot but getting things done and being a good man he is.Karrsin is black and white we adopted her and when a child is born love is the only emotion they have the others are taught.My vote you will get all the change you promise work hard on it .And I hope one day we will see people not color.It took our baby to show us.

  3. I agree that so far neither party is willing to “solve” healthcare. I guess we’ll just wait for the crisis brought on by political inaction and ideology. If you think the mortgage backed securities bailout is expensive wait for the healthcare bailout.

  4. I Find it likely that this election season will turn out as boring as the rest. A Bunch of rambling about a health plan makeover that will never happen is still rambling about the impossible.

  5. Joe Biden is certainly the solid choice, and therefore a boring one. Other than a history of a messianic obsession to create stupid and draconian legislation about ecstasy use, and the ability to plagiarize an equally boring Welshman, Biden’s Senate career has been wrapped up in middle of the road Democratic foreign relations wonkery. And ye he did vote for the Iraq war and there’s plenty of blame to go around for that. What he adds to the ticket is beyond me, but it certainly ain’t no interest in health care, unless you think that adding a bunch of club-rave-druggies to the prison health care system reflects an interest in health care.