Uncategorized

TECH: Microsoft Healthvault

Microsoft released its new Health Vault system this morning. You can read lots about it all over the Internet (NY Times article here).

Briefly the Health Vault allows you to save searches and information you’ve collected on the Internet, also data from devices like blood glucose meters and peak flow meters, and finally the ability to store data from various places (e.g. PHR companies, EMRs etc). I’ll be checking in with some of those partners later in the week.

Microsoft swore blind to me that this has been vetted by the privacy crowd (including the more, ahem, extreme among them) and that all this data will be totally portable to other storage applications.

The money will come from people using search, not from (as Peter Neupert said at Health2.0) putting a toll between patient and doctor.

So with Intuit already making noises, Dossia possibly back on track, Microsoft launching, and Google still working on something similar, the games really are beginning. I’ll be back to comment later.

Livongo’s Post Ad Banner 728*90

Categories: Uncategorized

Tagged as:

15
Leave a Reply

15 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
12 Comment authors
R MontagueR MontagueClyde BennettNot sayingRandy Bak, MD Recent comment authors
newest oldest most voted
R Montague
Guest
R Montague

uh…to be fair, I did keep trying and after leaving the HealthyCircle website, re-booting and logging back in, I was successful in backdating some sample weight data. I also succeeded in entering updated weight data for today, though much to my chagrin, it went in 3 or 4 times…but still can’t delete them.
Not a quitter in any sense, and will just see how it really works out in the long run

R Montague
Guest
R Montague

After playing with the HealthVault website and finding it quite user-unfriendly, I will probably remove the (Microsoft) software and use the space for a game. Discovering that after making a couple of entry errors (on it’s HealthyCircle partnership website), I found that my data charts will be forever skewed as there is no way to change the entered (and incorrect)data. Likewise, I find there is no way to enter data for a previous day (perhaps broken software). Any gap in data will then be charted as a straight line which would of course remove any “peaks and valleys” occuring in… Read more »

Clyde Bennett
Guest
Clyde Bennett

It thought one of the purposes of the CCHIT was to develop standards to allow EHR’s to import and export data from/to different EHR software products. I see no mention in any of Healthvault’s online SDK info about using this as a standard. So much for cooperation . . .

Vijay Goel, M.D.
Guest

Not saying has a great point. As we enter an era of consumerism in medicine, we must start to cater to the consumer mindset– the same one that makes BMW spend a lot of time on getting the “thump” of closing the door just right and made Volvo add curves to a previously boxy (but extremely safe) product.
This brings up an interesting point–what is sexy when it comes to healthcare?

Not saying
Guest

Hmmm … for once it looks like Microsoft may have an edge over Google. You get the feeling they’re not going to have face quite the same level of criticism over their privacy policies as Google will.
WSJ did something on this today … the money quote:
“Consumers are just not that excited about these” services, said Elizabeth Boehm, an analyst at Forrester Research Inc.
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB119150675511948912.html?mod=health_home_stories
The evidence suggests that the American public does not buy things it thinks are boring. Ever. So how do you solve that?

Randy Bak, MD
Guest
Randy Bak, MD

I’m curious about the privacy features–I guess I’ll need to open an account to see what there is (though I worry about what kind of personal profile I’ll create if I go dink around).
Where is the lab data? Where is the medication data? Why aren’t these companies partners? Perhaps getting paid for valuable data is the issue, but I’m sure everyone will blame the complexities of consent. Ask for emr uploads, and the doctor’s office becomes the data entry resource for the project.

Neal Evans, Ph.D.
Guest

One quick comment to Dr. Levin, actually there is a PHR that is built to use HealthVault as a ‘data source/target’: it is CapMed’s PHR (which my company helped CapMed build). The current version that launched with HealthVault is ‘icePHR’, with a more full-feature version coming very soon. jd makes a great point that is right on the money. In my experience on both the clinical side and the patient/consumer side, the PHRs will click once there is very tight integration with EMRs (and payer too, for that matter). CapMed’s approach addresses this, I believe, as HealthVault is treated as… Read more »

jd
Guest
jd

Gary, what do mean you wonder whether payors will reimburse for it? What is there to reimburse? Payors are interested in whether physicians have EMRs, not PHRs, because the EMRs can be used for efficient and accurate data aggregation for quality measures. The main limitation of this PHR, and any clinical PHR for the large majority of Americans, is that very little clinical information right now is stored in a searchable database. You need widespread use of EMRs before this is really useful, because people aren’t going to take the time to enter their own data by hand. I think… Read more »

Gary Levin M.D.
Guest

See my comments at http://healthtrain.blogspot.com
It is not a PHR….lots of fancy “telemedicine” here, but wonder if payors will reimburse for it.
Not easy to configure for the average non techy over age 60 who are the patients that will need this type of monitoring….gml

Mark SIngh MD
Guest

As a practicing physician, I’m really excited about this application and have signed up for a personal account. My plan is to start enrolling my patients with the hope of consolidating their medical data. I found however that the application did not have a place for me to enter my past medical history, medication lists etc. I think, for this application to work for my patients, this feature needs to be in place. Perhaps this feature already exists. If this is the case, it needs to be more obvious to the user. I know this is in beta, so I’m… Read more »

MG
Guest
MG

Didn’t mean to just sound critical. This develop does address several shortfalls with the current generation of PHR solutions. Additionally, Microsoft seems to be realistic about how customers will use and adapt these solutions. That is a positive step for the industry. It is particularly interesting that they got the primary privacy gurus on board too.
It should be interesting as you said.

Matthew Holt
Guest

Actually Matt, Allscripts has signed on. So we’ll see…

MG
Guest
MG

I also noticed that none of the really large acute EMR vendors (Epic, Cerner, and GE) hadn’t signed on either. Going to make it tough to get data from hospitals with these systems I imagine.

MG
Guest
MG

Sounds like a really interesting tool but I was most intrigued by the list of partnerships that Microsoft signed and the supposed open development. There are some impressive partners on board including a few of the leading vendors in the PHR space (CapMed, Medem, etc) and a few of the leading EMR vendors. One thing I don’t see is a single health plan, clearinghouse, or PBM on board. This likely means no access to claims data of any form. Fairly predictable since the one real value point that payers are sitting on right now – especially the national guys –… Read more »

Vijay Goel, M.D.
Guest

Its interesting that so many data companies are coming into this space– they will pull health information in formats that can be mined– and how that interacts with future payment models will be interesting. You may expect that insurance underwriters will go crazy trying to get at this information– and likely increase the dispersion of health premiums between the healthy and those most at risk. It will also be interesting to see if a de-facto standard like XML rises from these data-warehousing efforts. The other alternative is the continuation of the format wars we have today, which would mean that… Read more »