Uncategorized

INDUSTRY: Medical Bankruptcy Rate Disputedby Eric Novack

For those who remember the endless headlines of "50% of All
Bankruptcies Due to Medical Debt", and particularly for those who have
based many calls for national, single-payer health care, on that paper
by Single-payer zealot David Himmelstein, here is a must read.  Law
professor Todd Zywicki, testifying at the US House of Representatives
Judiciary Committee, this week. The link to the testimony is a downloadable word file… all 21 pages are worth reading.

Livongo’s Post Ad Banner 728*90

Categories: Uncategorized

Tagged as: ,

10
Leave a Reply

10 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
6 Comment authors
ejumonMike SmithAlexBuzzPeter Recent comment authors
newest oldest most voted
ejumon
Guest
ejumon

Ultimately, we should raise the baseline of care in America. It would be absolutely un-American to socialize it absolutely… All American children have access to public education, but we send our kids to the best private schools if we can. Don’t we? It is not a perfect system, but most people would say we are better off with a public education system, even though we pay taxes for it..

Peter
Guest
Peter

This criticism of the study is not new. Here is a link to one stating pretty much the same things in February 2005. http://www.nationalreview.com/comment/heriot200502110735.asp Professor Gail Heriot states: “Maybe that’s why only 28.3 percent of the surveyed debtors themselves agreed with the authors that their bankruptcy was substantially caused by “illness or injury.” The rest put the blame elsewhere, even when the study labeled their problems as at least in part “medical.”” “Buried in the study is the fact that only 27 percent of the surveyed debtors had unreimbursed medical expenses exceeding $1,000 over the course of the two years… Read more »

Mike Smith
Guest
Alex
Guest
Alex

I like this formula. Just do a study with a laughable methodology. Assert it as fact. When it is debunked all the people who have been using it as ammo can say “it’s not important whether it’s true or not.”
Well, it is important. It is important to not distort findings and to not lie to try to prove a point. Health Affairs should be ashamed of themselves for publishing that piece of crap in the first place.

Peter
Guest
Peter

Re-reading my last post I find I mischarcterized the healthcare industry participating in bribes. That is not proveable and needs to be retracted. I really meant to say that there is a lot of money (millions) spent by the healthcare industry in lobbying politicians and giving political donations. Sorry, I sometimes get ahead of myself.

Peter
Guest
Peter

“(1) U.S. culture is radically different than others” No kidding. On healthcare others say “WE” in the U.S. they say “ME”. “2) they have never offered to move there” I still hold my Canadian Citizenship. “3) they’ve never seriously studied the other country’s policies,” Been there, lived there, know it from the inside. Had cataract surgery there for 1/2 the cost. Will go back to have any more surgery done for 1/2 the cost. Care to come with me? “Because I know that even well-funded, well-run national health plans CANNOT fund every major medical crisis.” Just ask U.S. insurance companies… Read more »

Buzz
Guest
Buzz

ARE WE CANADA? IMHO, the most laughable parts of when someone Utopian Socialist says that the U.S. should be France-UK-Canada-Cuba-whatever when they fail to note: (1) U.S. culture is radically different than others, (2) they have never offered to move there, (3) they’ve never seriously studied the other country’s policies, and (4) they never account for current changes (e.g., UK/CDN changes in medical privatization, French auto fires). Of course, a major incident causes financial changes. Like my former live-in love at an Ivy medical school — she owes $125,000 and Mariah Carey’s nephew is debt-free. Am I supposed to resent… Read more »

Peter
Guest
Peter

Thought I’d throw this into the debate. “Bankruptcy Rates in the Canada and the US – The huge disparity is because of the health care system. The US bankruptcy rate (6.9 per thousand) for the year 2004 is more than twice as high as the Canadian bankruptcy rate (2.6 per thousand). The main reason for the huge disparity in bankruptcy rates in Canada and the US is because of the different health care systems in the two countries. Canada has universal health care for all citizens paid for out of taxes. The US system is based on private enterprise mainly… Read more »

Peter
Guest
Peter

Ah yes, where does the accumulation of other debt and medical debt really force a person into bankruptcy. What comes first, accumulation of medical debt then other debt, or other debt and then unexpected and uncontrollable medical debt? Do people take on medical debt, or does medical debt come on its own? If only the debtor could get rid of the house payments and car payments and credit card payments, then that medical debt would be payable. I’m not ready yet, after reading all 21 pages, to accept Professor Zywicki’s conclusions. He makes some contradicting statements. He examines other studies,… Read more »

Neimon
Guest
Neimon

That NO ONE should have to declare bankruptcy as a result of a medical issue is obviously unimportant. Let’s continue to hold committee meetings on whether to order the Titanic’s deck chairs in a line or a circle.