4
Leave a Reply

4 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
3 Comment authors
Tom LeithAnanonRick Recent comment authors
newest oldest most voted
Tom Leith
Guest
Tom Leith

> people are starting to catch on about the practical
> differences between for-profit and nonprofit entities.
Hmmmmm. I must have missed something. What are the practical differences? The State of Illinois, the IRS, and now evidently The City of Los Angeles have independently raised this question…
t

Rick
Guest
Rick

HCA being a publicly traded company, its margins are in the public domain, so I don’t see where there’d be a cause of action.
And you’re right about the public perception of hospitals, although people are starting to catch on about the practical differences between for-profit and nonprofit entities.

Ananon
Guest
Ananon

Rick, Insurance companies could be in breach of contract if they openly say to the public “we think this hospital has a profit margin of X” or even if they say that “this hospital is profitable.” At that point, the hospital has the right to sue the insurance company, not just for trying to say something it may not have the right to say, but for doing something that may constitute “steerage,” which none of the contracts allow. This is a problem everywhere – you can thank the AHA and the AMA for this, and for all the other reasons… Read more »

Rick
Guest
Rick

Seeing how fat-and-happy HealthOne is, one has to wonder what would make UnitedHealth capitulate with them in their contentious contracting battle. I understand United may have been bleeding membership, losing it to CIGNA and Aetna among others. But it seems to me if United had more carefully orchestrated its media campaign during the contracting dispute, it might have come out better off.
But then, nobody ever accused United of knowing how to effectively manage public perception.