POLICY: Florida solves Medicaid cost problem (well, not really)

As you’d expect from the most efficient, transparent, clean-government minded state in the nation, Florida has figured out how to solve its Medicaid cost problem. It’s planning on privatizing Medicaid and making recipients buy in with a voucher into managed care plans. I said plenty about Medicaid in a post last week, so I won’t repeat it all. But three things struck me. First, according to the leader of Florida’s Democrats, the Medicaid budget is about to overtake the education budget. I know they have lots of old and poor people down there, but can that really be true? (I’d like to understand this explanatory page but unless I’m pretty dumb it contradicts itself in the notes below the table). In California where we rival Mississippi in propping up the table on per capita education spending, health spending is only a third of education spending. So is Florida really spending no money on educating its kids? The California state budget division is below, and it shows that we spend a lot less on health than on education.

(From California Budget Basics, by Stephen Levy).

Secondly, 70% of Medicaid dollars in most states go on the care of the poor, elderly and disabled, mostly on nursing home care. No managed care organization has a clue how to deal with those folks, so really we are talking about saving money (potentially) by going after only the other 30% of the dollars. Not really much likelihood of big savings there.

Finally, states are the FILOs of budget deficits (first in, last out). But if you believe the Bush rhetoric about how the economy is getting better (and assuming you are a governor named Bush you should do), shouldn’t this picture be getting better? And if it is, why does it need radical surgery now?

If you want to dive a little deeper into Medicaid, you might take a look at this McKinsey report on what’s wrong with Medicaid which gives some ideas for fixing it. While it’s not dumb as far as it goes, the report doesn’t unfortunately mention the actual ways Medicaid really needs to get fixed which are:a) rolling it into a universal health insurance system,b) creating a national long term care policy, andc) doing something about the scandalous state of the poor in America.

Jonathan Cohn summed it up well in an email in which he said that:

What I love is the constant dismay at the way Medicaid keeps eating up larger shares of state budgets, as if it didn’t have something to do with the fact that more and more people are becoming eligible as employer-sponsored insurance withers away.

Categories: Uncategorized

Tagged as: ,

1 reply »

  1. Were do I begin, Florida is so bad in most of it’s issues. But Medicaid is a disaster. The paper work in so unreal I am so lost. I was on Medicaid in NJ then I had to move here because of my landlord job was transferred. My history is not the issue. I get 600.00 for SSI and requested Medicaid to offset the cost not covered from Medicare. I requested help for co pays because of limited monies for housing and personal care. Not food stamps no extra money just cover co-pays. I make to much money at 600.00 total. Even Medicare people say Florida and Calif. are the worst for coverage. But as I drove around I saw a bridge to no were in Pasco county it goes to a trailer park over the suncoast parkway. Above crystal river off 19 north you will find and 8 mile canal under another bridge that goes no were was to cross Florida. I cannot get a 60.00 dollar heart doctor bill paid.