
By ANDREW TSANG
(Part 1 is here)
The Healthcare Economy’s Smoking Gun
That is the generous side of the accounting, where healthcare produces benefits other industries get to keep. The other side coming in shows that healthcare treats damage other industries get paid to cause. Due to size alone, tobacco use is the best example. A cigarette company books a sale and keeps the profit. The lung disease shows up years later, in a clinic, on an insurer’s claim, in a hospital bed, and the company never sees that bill. Cigarettes are a textbook example of a negative externality, a product whose harm lands on people who were never part of the sale. Smoking generated more than $240 billion in healthcare spending. The bill got big enough that states sued the tobacco companies to claw back the public money spent treating smokers, and a 1998 settlement with forty-six states still has them paying. It took a nationwide legal fight to send even part of smoking’s bill back out of healthcare.

Part of what we call healthcare’s cost problem is really the cost of everybody else’s products. The smoker’s cancer treatment still enters the accounts as healthcare spending, where it joins the evidence that healthcare costs too much. Yes – hospitals can overcharge, insurers can overburden, and drugs can be overprescribed. But this patient arrived with a disease a cigarette company was paid to cause! Fixing the billing department won’t undo what put them in the bed.
Continue reading…






