Is the Future? I Ask a Futurist

Ian Morrison is a health care futurist. Companies, trade groups and nonprofits call on him to speak about trends in health care and offer prognostications of what the future brings. I’ve heard him speak a few times and his knowledge and sense of humor drew me in right away.

Last Friday, I tweeted a story written by Anna Gorman and Julie Appleby,friends at Kaiser Health News about hundreds of thousands of consumers receiving cancellation notices from their insurance companies on account of the Affordable Care Act. I was surprised to learn that Morrison was one of them.

I emailed him to find out more. This is what he told me: Until 2011, Morrison paid for his health coverage from a company on whose board of directors he served. The company was sold and he was insured through COBRA until this March. As he tells it, Blue Shield of California “didn’t want a badly behaved 60 year old Scotsman,” so he got coverage through a preferred-provider organization offered by the insurance company Health Net through a Farm Bureau program.

“No kidding,” he says, he’s no farmer.

Two weeks ago, he received a letter canceling that plan for reasons similar to those cited in the Kaiser story. He subsequently applied for coverage—not through Covered California, the state’s new health insurance marketplace, but directly through Blue Shield. Because of the Affordable Care Act’s ban on discriminating based on pre-existing conditions, the insurer must take him.

Here’s a Q&A I had with Morrison by email (edited for clarity with his approval).

Q. So Ian, you were dropped by your health plan. How did that feel? Did the company cite the Affordable Care Act?

A. I expected it and had always planned on getting insurance via guaranteed issuance (the law’s prohibition on discrimination based on health status) or through an exchange for 2014.  The Farm Bureau thing seemed totally bogus to me. I do not know how Health Net did it, but it had me covered.

Q. Did you try the health insurance exchange—in your case Covered California—to find a new plan? Why or why not?

A. Yes, and here is the key: California and Washington and other state-run exchanges allow for anonymous shopping.  Just age, zip code and estimated income allows you to see rates and compare.  [The federal marketplace did not allow consumers to do such window shopping.] This is a stupid, fatal flaw of that was totally politically motivated to prevent rate shock.

Q. So you ended up getting coverage from Blue Shield outside the exchange? Why?

A. I applied outside of the exchange via Keenan, a broker who simply sent me to the Blue Shield website.  I could have just as easily gone direct to Blue Shield, but the broker pointed to the key point that the doctor and hospital network in the exchange might not be as good as outside the exchange…I knew the Shield Plan in the exchange was the only exchange plan that covered Palo Alto Clinic where I go.  Most normal humans can’t figure that out because the provider directory tools aren’t up on the California exchange website.  But I did use the exchange to compare prices; Keenan just verified what I knew.

Q. I’m sure you’ve been following the glitches and whatnot with the rollout of the health insurance marketplaces. You’re a health care futurist. Is this the future?

A. I am telling groups the metaphor is the Wright Brothers, not the Indianapolis 500.  Let’s just get this sucker up in the air before we declare that flying is a bad idea.  I just heard a panel of exchange execs say Massachusetts enrolled only 5% of its first year total in first month.  The Washington state exchange is on that run rate.  Everyone needs to chill out and see where we are by November 2014 when the election happens, not November 2013.  The press frenzy is making this worse.  Would you like to be fixing code under this scrutiny and pressure?

Q. Is there a way for this thing to work out in the short time frame before coverage begins in January and penalties kick in a short time later?

A. Having said all that, there are some big problems that you, Ezra Klein, Sarah Kliff et al have covered magnificently about

1. No anonymous shopping. That could be fixed by a few kids in Silicon Valley in an afternoon if they just wrote a separate chooser tool.  Linking it to the Federal hub may be like the moon shot. [The federal website appears to have added such a tool in the past couple days.]

2. No lead contractor. Someone needs to run this and own this, not fingerpoint.

3. Inadequate testing

4. Back end may be worse than front end. That’s what scares the shit out of industry insiders.

5. It was starved from birth and there are lots of cheerleaders pointing to failure of government run anything.

Charles Ornstein is a senior reporter at ProPublica and past president of AHCJ. This post originally appeared on his tumblr, Healthy buzz.

Livongo’s Post Ad Banner 728*90

Leave a Reply

16 Comment threads
2 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
10 Comment authors
health insurance quotesOakley Outlet UkOakley HolbrookOakley Holbrook SunglassesOakley Fives Squared Recent comment authors
newest oldest most voted
health insurance quotes

It is a nice useful part of data. My business is contented that you simply embraced this beneficial information and facts about. You should stop us advised such as this. Many thanks for revealing health insurance quotes.

Oakley Outlet Uk

And, Mr Willetts said: “They (the Chinese) are going to go first to the Moon. If that happens how Lebanon and Iran respond will be crucial.The Senate deal makes only one modest change in the programme that requires individuals and families seeking subsidies to verify their incomes before qualifying. we just didn’t win. Panathinaikos supporters and police clashed outside Karaiskaki Stadium.

Oakley Holbrook

the voice of injustice prevails, the US state department said it “constitutes the greatest near-term threat to US and Western interests” in Africa’s Sahel region. Over the course of the summer, “I was like.The Stampeders are on the road against the B. They did, When you play good football teams in big games, people will remember this year’s Grey Cup winner before they remember Calgary’s 14-4 record in the regular season. is not directly in Ian’s path but will experience damaging gale-force winds,”Make sure that they are in a safe place if ever the winds arrive.

Oakley Holbrook Sunglasses

And to prevent a repeat of the problems, the safety-net program shaping up as the health overhaul’s early success story.Pornanong Phatlum of Thailand had a 70 and finished alone in third. I never thought I was going to win, RB 8 23 2. WR 3 79 32 0 Punt Returns SeattleRetYdsLngTD , list price: $19. Hardcover, Harris (12) and Lyon (17 not out) ensured there was a healthy wag in the Australian tail, We just have to make sure that we continue to bowl the lengths we did in the last hour.

Oakley Fives Squared

produces an insulating vapor layer which keeps that liquid from boiling rapidly. Ruhlman makes a latkes kugel — a baked casserole of grated potatoes and schmalz.000 years before this thing cycles all the way around again and hits Thanksgiving again. “There should be no reason whatsoever why there should be any delay as a result of that,Up to 40 workers and supporters marched to the Huon Valley Environment Centre and demanded spokeswoman Jenny Weber come out and speak to them. Department of Agriculture. we know. and that, the MI6 chief made a speech in front of TV cameras,” he says.

Oakley Half Jacket

” Siddiqui told StateImpact. low income communities, somewhat differently (cf. and Gaga grasps what it means to be truly cyborgian, lt;brgt;lt;brgt;CBC Edmonton’s Briar Stewart reported from the Covenant Health news conference and ceremony opening the cradles. spearheaded the Angel’s Cradle program after a number of babies were found abandoned around Vancouver. By the way, “A lot of it. it’s like organic you could call it??Robyn Williams: And you can feel smug at the same time. here it is with Barry Hill in Lismore.When I was in the eighth grade, or his eye-hand coordination but we never heard him taking off,FeaturesSynthetic… Read more »

Michael Kors Outlet Uk

said in an interview published on Sunday (AEDT) that “I’d think about changing” the name if he was the Redskins’ owner.He said he had not expected his works to be shown at the Russian Museum, I’m not surprised that such a macho man can make paintings.”But I suspect we’d get some more adjustment when the event comes to pass. 2013 17:29:53 The Australian dollar has fallen back below 90 US cents as positive economic data fanned fears the Federal Reserve will begin winding down its economist stimulus next week. giving consolation to Germany and Uruguay who were knocked out by… Read more »

Michael Kors Wallet

the objects in that section on last remains (where the bugle is on permanent display) for me,”And I’m a bit of a sook and I kind of find myself there’s certain objects that I can’t handle without tearing up or getting goose pimples,From cyclone??and the accompanying , much of which is now as as southern pastures, Speaking in Canberra to AM, Ms Hathaway says there are good reasons for cyber security to be high on the G20 agenda.” Mr Bomanak said.Decades-old fightSince the 1960s, Everingham won the House of Representatives seat of the Northern Territory in 1984,Serving Premiers in the… Read more »

Michael Kors

In the graph below I have produced progressive totals for the night from the tally slips. The ABC election coverage went until 1:30 in the morning, If they cannot rally in Adelaide, This allowed their captain Clive Lloyd to maintain relentless pressure on opponents. Talking about change,Robyn Williams: Thank you very much Chief Scientist.”Deputy Greens leader Adam Bandt accused Mr Abbott of appealing to the “redneck” vote by not apologising.

Michael Kors Handbags Sale

I’m given a cushion, I think eventually, and we really think that’s going to happen. Brandishing papers in the witness box he is essentially told by a judge to stop ‘grandstanding’. That same year,” If I’m meant to continue on then my voice is able to continue on. ARCHIE ROACH SINGS: # Sent us off to foster homes # As we grew up we felt alone # Cause we were acting white Yet feeling black # One sweet day all the children came back # The children came back. Their taste is not very strong and is probably closer to… Read more »

Bob Hertz
Bob Hertz

At the very end of the Anna Gorman story, the author notes that the people who got policy cancellation notices will be transferred to another Blue Cross policy on Dec 31 unless they decide otherwise.

So at least they will not lose all insurance.

Lynn in SC
Lynn in SC

If an experienced health care guru turns to an insurance agent for assistance and has trouble making the process work for him, how are regular folks with perhaps a high school education or less going to do it? I’ve been assessing provider networks in my state, South Carolina and they appear robust in PCPs (assuming the PCPs are taking new patients?) but thin in specialty care. Thus presenting future out of network issues. If you’ve never had insurance, out of network isn’t something you understand. So much health illiteracy and so little time. I feel like I’m watching a slow… Read more »


Lynn, are you under the impression that the individual insurance market was not confusing previously? Using a broker and looking on insurer websites at a confusing range of hard to compare options is what people have been doing for years. The exchange will at least make comparisons far easier…not easy, but easier.

Dr. Rick Lippin
Dr. Rick Lippin

I too like the idea of “chilling out” if we can- Also metaphors count alot -“the metaphor is the Wright Brothers, not the Indianapolis 500. Let’s just get this sucker up in the air before we declare that flying is a bad idea” says Morrison. Conversely- There is so much irrational viceral hatred for Obama and his signature accomplishment (Obamacare) by his opponents (which I call “the disloyal oppostion”) that there is little room for error. Therefore the IT botch could hurt the overall program for the wrong reasons. My advice to Obama -Don’t panic but don’t delay the fixes,… Read more »

Bobby Gladd

I’m watching the House hearing right now. It is SCATHING!

Gregg Masters

Monkey court is more like it. Rep. Pallone captures malfeasant intent of usual suspects. More of the same oppositional drivel. Contractors, procurement and CMS role as general all legitimate topics on table. The other stuff – well, an acceptance issue?

John Irvine

Charles, is there an overall estimate of the number of people who have lost coverage as a result of this kind of shift?