So Much For “Everyone Can Get Care In An Emergency Room”

We’ve long argued this meme isn’t true. But now it’s explicitly false:

Last year, about 80,000 emergency-room patients at hospitals owned by HCA, the nation’s largest for-profit hospital chain, left without treatment after being told they would have to first pay $150 because they did not have a true emergency.

Led by the Nashville-based HCA, a growing number of hospitals have implemented the pay-first policy in an effort to divert patients with routine illnesses from the ER after they undergo a federally required screening. At least half of all hospitals nationwide now charge upfront ER fees, said Rick Gundling, vice president of the Healthcare Financial Management Association, which represents health-care finance executives.

So sure you can get non-emergent care in an ED – if you pay for it out of pocket. Please understand I’m not saying that all care should be free. I’m saying that the emergency department is no different than a physician’s office. If you have insurance, or can pay for care yourself, you get it. Otherwise, you don’t. No matter where you are.

Why is this happening?

Hospital officials say the upfront payments are a response to mounting bad debt caused by the surge in uninsured and underinsured patients and to reduced reimbursements by some private and government insurers for patients who use the ER for routine care.

And what about prescriptions?

In December, Skaggs Regional Medical Center in Branson, Mo., began asking ER patients to pay $40 or their insurance co-payment before receiving a prescription.

“If they don’t pay . . . they won’t be given their prescription,” hospital spokeswoman Michelle Leroux said.

The strategy is designed to help the hospital deal with spiraling, unpaid ER bills. About a third of the 120 patients treated daily in the hospital’s ER are uninsured. The change was implemented after the ER reported $1.3 million in bad debt for August.

So please, don’t keep arguing that everyone has access to health care because they can just go to the emergency room.

Aaron E. Carroll, MD, MS is an associate professor of Pediatrics and the associate director of Children’s Health Services Research at Indiana University School of Medicine, as well as the director of the Center for Health Policy and Professionalism Research. Carroll’s work has been featured in The New York Times, USA Today, The Los Angeles Times, Newsweek, and many other national publications. He blogs at The Incidental Economist, where this post was originally published.

Livongo’s Post Ad Banner 728*90

Leave a Reply

4 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
4 Comment authors
Joe CrazelHubert WillistonMD as HELLBryan C Recent comment authors
newest oldest most voted
Joe Crazel
Joe Crazel

What is the purpose of and EMR (electronic medical record)? It allow easy tracking of patient outcomes by the Government, Insurance companies and other institutions including the doctor. What helps an EMR be a good one? It is important for the EMR to be user friendly and provide safety in use. A good EMR is easy to use especially when documenting values that are normal, and help offset extra time by creating shortcuts for these normal values. Default usual dosing of medication is important to help the doctor avoid prescribing too little or too much, and will point out interactions… Read more »

Hubert Williston
Hubert Williston

Some of the lack of emphasis on primary care may be coming back to bite us!! Most of all this supports the fact that we do not have a health care system and when someone who speaks from experience and reason like Don Berwick he is shouted down and ushered off the stage.


Sounds like a dream come true. ERs should be divided into the EMTALA ZONE, the EMERGENCY ROOM, and the Cash & Carry clinic.

Everyone gets the mandates screaming exam for medical stability. That is “free”. If you are”Medically Stable”, then the free stuff is over.

What is wrong with that?

Co-pays can only be required after a medical screening exam finds the patient is stable.

So, yes,everyone has access to needed care. NOT unnecessary care, like most pediatrics.

Bryan C
Bryan C

We are in an untenable situation – ERs cannot continue to provide free care for patients who do not have an emergency. There are only so many resources; diverting them away from heart attack and acute appendicitis patients for ear aches and dental pain, along with medication refills – all things that can be taken care of by a primary care doctor as a non-emergency – is not only appropriate but necessary for the continued functioning of our current system and our promise (and federal law) that medical care FOR EMERGENCIES will continue to be provided in our emergency departments.