Physicians

The Numbers Tell The Story

Yesterday, athenahealth and Sermo released our Physician Sentiment Index℠ (PSI). With over 1,000 physicians polled, the national survey is thought to be the largest of its kind.  While many of the findings will come as no surprise to physicians in practice, the messages are nevertheless alarming.  Key findings include:

  • 64% cited the current healthcare climate as somewhat or very detrimental to their delivery of quality care
  • Only 22% are optimistic about the ability of the American physician to practice independently or in small groups
  • 59% are of the mind that the quality of medicine in America will decline in next five years; only 18% believe the quality of medicine will improve
  • The majority (54%) strongly disagree/disagree that more active government involvement in healthcare regulation can improve outcomes; less than a quarter feel otherwise
  • A shift from fee-for-service to pay-for-performance gives hope to almost half (49%) who think it will have a very/somewhat positive impact quality of care but;
    • 53 percent believe pay-for-performance will have a negative/very negative impact on the effort required to get paid

View full PSI survey results (PDF)

Working with athenahealth and THCB, Sermo plans to publicize these findings to help the general public understand what is really happening in our healthcare system today and establish a sentiment indicator that can generate longitudinal trend data in this area.  In the next phase of the athenahealth-Sermo relationship, we’ll be building off these findings to explore ways that physicians can run their practices more efficiently and level the playing field with insurers.

Daniel Palestrant, MD is the Founder & CEO of Sermo, Inc.  A frequent contributor to THCB, his work also appears on the FtF blog at Sermo.com, where this piece first appeared.

Livongo’s Post Ad Banner 728*90

12
Leave a Reply

12 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
8 Comment authors
OlenerbarexhaustedMDBrad FPeter Recent comment authors
newest oldest most voted
Olene
Guest

.

Peter
Guest
Peter

exhausted, I don’t see any Republicans refusing taxpayer paid cadillac plan health insurance so that their not be hypocritical.
Also, would anything make you happy?

Margalit Gur-Arie
Guest

rbar, I think you have it exactly right.
I would also add the observation that a majority of physicians are politically conservative and the current circumstances are bound to adversely affect their “sentiments”.
Not to mention that in this economy you would be hard pressed to find a sector with rosier sentiments about the immediate future.

rbar
Guest
rbar

I cannot speak for my fellow colleagues, but of course I hear and read from them daily: the simple explanation for the pervasive unhappiness is the fact that things (working conditions, pay) go constantly downhill. In my opinion, they are still at a satisfactory level for most doctors incl. usually haredworking PCPs. They earn a decent living and usually can bring their kids through college. But of course, all this is RELATIVE, comparing current conditions/pay to the situation of stock brokers, realtors, physicians in the 70s and 80s, and most importantly, their colleagues doing procedures sours the mood. And the… Read more »

exhaustedMD
Guest
exhaustedMD

this is the third time trying to comment here in the past 12 hours, so hope it works: Thanks for this post. It needs not just said, documented, and confirmed, but also accepted by the masses. A lot of physicians do NOT support this legislation. Accept it and figure it into future actions! By the way, to all you legislation supporters, explain to us reasonable and fair citizens, why does the President, his cabinet, and the major legislative leaders and formulators of this legislation NOT have to be covered by it? Go to Politico.com, a March 24 post, and read… Read more »

Brad F
Guest
Brad F

I am very suspect of a physician poll that indicates 59% of docs feel quality will deteriorate over the next 5 years. Specious at best.
When 30-40% of health care providers cannot achieve appropriate levels of hand hygiene (not QI rocket science by any means), as they say, Houston, we have a a problem. That is just a drop in the bucket…
Believe me, it can only go up from here. I live and breathe it every day–take my word.
Brad

Peter
Guest
Peter

I don’t think the survey has much insight as it lumps all physicians together in their opinions. But having lived in Canada for most of my life and having known more than a few docs there and here through my wife as a nurse, I’ve never met a doctor that was happy – with anything. How do you please this bunch? Tom, I guess you may be able to understand how non-docs struggle to get their kids into/through college. I’m for paying PCPs more but it’ll have to come at the expense of specialists and/or other parts of the system.… Read more »

Margalit Gur-Arie
Guest

“Utilization is key. We have to shape up, or we have to ration.” There is a third option. Managing unit costs down. Since shaping up is unlikely to produce any immediate results, and since rationing is unlikely to be acceptable to the public, physicians are rightfully concerned that the fees for their services will have to go down. Call it P4P or call it bundling or call it global budgets or call it coordination of care, the net effect will be a reduction in physicians and hospitals income, and it will have to be driven by the Government through Medicare.… Read more »

Ken
Guest
Ken

Gerber,
Are you suggesting that the health care reform law was drafted by people who know nothing about health care (like lawyers trying to fix Toyota)?
I thought a lot of health care experts put in their input/feedback into the law, and many of them believe this piece of legislation is (albeit not perfect) a good start.
Who do you suggest should have drafted the law?
Physicians or insurance company execs, since they have “in depth knowledge of insurance or the practice of medicine”?

Lawrence J. Kramer
Guest

Doctors, specialists, anyway, have a reason to be concerned. The fact is that they cannot continue to make the money they make. The money isn’t there. I don’t mean that they can’t continue to charge what they charge. I mean that utilization will drop for the same reason that trees do not grow to the sky. Utilization will drop because utilization cannot not drop. The question is by what mechanism utilization will drop. Certainly, the least painful way for utilization to drop will be for people to get healthier. Socialized medicine (i.e.,any insured arrangement, whether through government or private carrier)… Read more »

Tom O'Brien
Guest

I just got off the phone with one of my best friends. He was (until 1 month ago) a primary care physician – the type who took tamales for payment from time to time.
He just joined a global pharma company as an executive because of the dismal prospect of putting his kids through college as a PCP in the current economic/health care environment.
It is a real loss – and I think the high levels of uncertainty over the next several years will cause lots of capable, smart docs to make career changes.
Tom O’Brien
@tomob

Gerber Medicare Supplement
Guest

The current health care “system” is definetly in need of reform, though the new legislation just looks to make health care more difficult. We have a 2,000+ page bill that was constructed by persons who do not have an in depth knowledge of insurance or the practice of medicine. It would be similar to having your attorney fix your faulty Toyota; your attorney knows nothing of your Toyota and its recall and you wouldn’t expect him to fix that issue. I feel the same way about our legislators…they are tying to fix problems they know nothing about. It will be… Read more »