Matthew Holt

McGuire not in prison. Reyes is. Anyone understand?

So Bill McGuire has settled with CALPers in the scandal where he backdated the value of his United HealthGroup stock options. He’ll pay a $30m fine which sounds a lot but is a rounding error on his net worth. So it appears that his troubles are over.

Meanwhile Gregory Reyes the CEO of Brocade did exactly the same thing and he’s doing 21 months in the big house as well as paying a similarly big fine.

For that matter Steve Jobs apparently did the same thing too, and just today Apple settled with the SEC for a mere $14 million (or about 8 minutes of iPhone sales) and Jobs himself doesn’t seem to be paying anything.

Isn’t there something about equal treatment under the law in one of those fuddy-duddy 18th century documents we Americans are so keen on? Can anyone explain the rationale behind these differences in treatment?

Livongo’s Post Ad Banner 728*90

18
Leave a Reply

18 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
9 Comment authors
DiogeniusRussellMatthew HoltFrankultrasound gel Recent comment authors
newest oldest most voted
Diogenius
Guest
Diogenius

far be it from me to stray off topic, but in the interest of clarity – is it Frank, or is it Russell?

Russell
Guest
Russell

So Frank, given what you do for a day job, can you explain why Reyes is in jail and McGuire and Jobs are not?

I’m a consultant, like you. You got any money? Like the Biden kid’s law firm — I’m not running a charity.
Post the answer. I’ll also need a signed contract and a credit card number.

Matthew Holt
Guest

So Frank, given what you do for a day job, can you explain why Reyes is in jail and McGuire and Jobs are not?

Frank
Guest
Frank

“Hillary’s deal is small potatoes in the universe of potential ill gotten gains.”
OK. One more time —
“My crooks are just as crooked as my opponent’s.”
What a great claim. Something to really be proud of.
Be sure to tell the kids.
What is common in crooks — Democrat, Republican or otherwise: they all have excuses and enablers.
Cry me a freakin’ river — I catch you stealing, you’re F’d.

Gregg Masters
Guest

Frank: you have a big job my friend. Lets talk about a level playing field with you in the bully pulpit as chief enforcer. I say you will have job security my friend. Lets start with cronyism, then talk about self serving corporate welfare, insider trading, and that all-to-cozy relationship between the fox and the hen house aka Wall Street and K street. I mean, let’s get real. 100 to 1 gains are common place with all too often zero transparency, and exceptions for the big dogs while the little guy gets hit with the “rule of law” theater and… Read more »

Frank
Guest
Frank

” .. of course we all now know how apolitical Bush USA’s appointees were under the Gonzalez reign ..”
Of course. That justifies a 100-1 return in nine months.
In a pig’s eye. (Without lipstick.)
Your crooks are just as crooked as your opponent’s. What a great claim. Something to really be proud of. Be sure to tell the kids.

Gregg Masters
Guest

Frank:
Your vitality is impressive, if not exhausting…..of course we all now know how apolitical Bush USA’s appointees were under the Gonzalez reign. Decades of impartiality and career over ideology sensibilities were eviscerated, and a once revered institution, the DOJ, is now somewhat credibility challenged.
Meanwhile, Hilliary did more to elevate the health reform debate than any one in the 90’s. While actual debate of pro-reform models were trounced by sound byte Harry and Louise “echolalia”, the failing health care system and its reform imperatives where merely kicked down the field only to resurface in 2008. Go figure?

Peter
Guest
Peter

Well Frank, I guess the Clintons get a freebee and Bush gets a freebee on Harken Energy. Not enough evidence in each.

Frank
Guest
Frank

What I know about the Clintons:
In over 25 years reviewing financial documents, including the “Fortune 500,” I’ve never seen a return on investment as high as Hilary’s gain in cattle futures.
Never.
I would never trust the Clintons with a penny of taxpayer funds. Not one penny.

Peter
Guest
Peter

Frank, then as a litigator you know there was not enough evidence to charge the Clintons.

Frank
Guest
Frank

Dear Clinton apologist: get a grip. If you have evidence that Judge Starr attempted to encourage perjury, as you suggest — bring it on. That’s a five-year felony.

Peter Pud: I’m a civil litigator. I investigate Democrats and Republcans — and jailed both. I know what it takes to convict.
Someone has something — I tell, let’s go, the govt. pays for informants with SOLID info.
If they don’t — I tell them to quit wasting everyone’s time and being a pinhead.

Peter
Guest
Peter

Frank, how old are you? “Boo, hoo, hoo”, really!
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Susan_McDougal

Frank
Guest
Frank

” .. But she stood up to Ken Star (sic) and his Grand Inquisitors and would not lie for them ..”
Dear Clinton apologist: get a grip. If you have evidence that Judge Starr attempted to encourage perjury, as you suggest — bring it on. That’s a five-year felony.
I’d bet $100 you can’t. People like you find facts and the law difficult to comprehend. Pity.
Facts is so hard. Boo, hoo, hoo.

ultrasound gel
Guest

Thanks for the postseo

Peter
Guest
Peter

I can still remember the “perp” walk of Susan McDougal of Whitewater fame paraded out in full ankle/wrist/waist chains like she was Hannibal Lector. But she stood up to Ken Star and his Grand Inquisitors and would not lie for them. It sure seems to be about friends in high places.