It’s all about the billing

Sean Neill is a South African-born, British-trained anesthesiologist, who recently relocated to Midwestern USA. He blogs regularly at OnMedica about his cross-cultural experience, frequently pointing out oddities of American health care.

Having arrived to see the last of the winter snow, we were amazed at how quickly spring and summer evolved.  Frozen pavements evolved to lush green grass in a matter of weeks.  Work is a 10 minute cycle away and most Americans find it humorous to see you arrive at the hospital in cycling gear.  When asking for directions, the reply is always in terms of driving, even if it is just around the corner.  One quickly learns to cycle on the wrong (right) side of the road as the vehicles are so large you would not want to make a mistake.

Another noticeable difference between health care in the UK and the USA is in terms of billing. A UK patient can go into an NHS hospital for a big procedure and may not be asked for another penny. It is completely different in America, where charges start from the minute you walk in the door. Each hospital specialty has its own large team of dedicated professionals diligently chasing every possible expense. A short visit to a primary health care facility will be followed by a bill within days.

The patients themselves tend to be sicker than what we are used to in the UK. A lot of them (and there are a lot of them) are simply huge! Nobody bats an eyelid at a BMI of 60.

Of course they all have OSA (obstructive sleep apnoea) and GERD (gastro-oesophageal reflux) and “mild” CHF (congestive heart failure). Clearly, there is nothing mild about having heart failure with one heart and two bodies, you can do the math. Abbreviations are the order of the day and the more abbreviated co-morbidities on the patients’ lists, the more they are charged. No matter how sick you are in the US it appears that if you have insurance you will get your operation.

Current estimates put US health care spending at approximately 16% of GDP. Total spending on health care in the UK rose to an estimated £120bn in 2006, representing 9.4% of GDP — up from 7.1% in 2001.

Perhaps one reason for NHS budget deficiencies is the fact that its billing structure is nowhere near as efficient or organized as the US. If UK citizens were allowed to forgo their National Insurance contributions in lieu of private health insurance, would they receive a better service or simply be charged more?

Livongo’s Post Ad Banner 728*90

Categories: Physicians

Tagged as: , , ,

Leave a Reply

5 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
5 Comment authors
AcompliaHector NazarioGregg MastersJordan GlogauPeter Recent comment authors
newest oldest most voted

Parents of primary school children are to receive an official letter from UK government intended to warn them if their child’s weight is above the healthy standards on the basis of their age under new plans complied by the Department of Health, UK. Schools regularly measure child’s height and weight at the age of 4-5 and again when they are between the ages of 10 and 11; however parents can opt to exempt their children from this process. The output of these measurements are used to calculate the body mass index (BMI) — an rough measure of fat in the… Read more »

Hector Nazario

Readers of THCB: Billing and restrictions on medical procedures can sometimes get out of hand in the US. Now this crisis is endangering the life of a promising young woman in Florida. Caitlin Jackson is a 19-year-old woman from Florida that is suffering from a rare brain disease called “Quiari Malformation.” The disease, which will eventually rob her of all motor functions, requires immediate surgery. On the day of her scheduled surgery, Aetna failed to approve the operation in time, and the hospital was forced to reschedule it to July 21st. Now, Aetna is openly refusing to pay for the… Read more »

Gregg Masters

Health care in the US is nearing an implosion tipping point. Admitted quality and access inequities in the bloated so called “system”, while somewhat masked by a here-to-for buoyant economy, have less cover as the financial and housing market meltdowns gain momentum and infect the general economy. We have much to learn from the UK, Germany, France and our neighbors to the north, au Canada. The arrogance to patently dismiss these models as government run, inefficient bureaucracies without merit to average Americans, will lose ground as more and more of us lose health insurance and join the ranks of the… Read more »

Jordan Glogau

I know your post was about patient facing issues but I am surprised that you didn’t mention the billing problems that anesthesiologists in particular have to face. If you are a faculty member of the hospital it’s not your problem but if you have privileges then you have to fend for yourself. The first issue is mechanical, in the States you can’t bill for your services until the surgeon has done his or her billing. Then we have the particularly arcane time based coding that anesthesiologists have to submit to get paid. This paper chase is part of the reason… Read more »


“If UK citizens were allowed to forgo their National Insurance contributions in lieu of private health insurance, would they receive a better service or simply be charged more?” If they used the NHS with private insurance I would think they would jump to the front of the line and pay more for the privilege. On the other hand those that could not afford private insurance would end up further down the line with less resources available to spend on their care. Don’t let Britain and the NHS get on that slippery slope. Your observations on the U.S. BMI are dead… Read more »