Uncategorized

HEALTH PLANS: Kaiser transplantation scandal-Will we ever know the truth?

Meanwhile, despite the fuss about the HealthConnect project–elsewhere the real Kaiser scandal may be whimpering out as the man behind it, Kaiser whistleblower David Merlin settled his lawsuit for unfair dismissal .

I had a very frank conversation about the kidney transplant issue with outgoing KP N.Cal President Mary Ann Thode during and after her keynote at UC Berkeley Haas health care conference on Feb 3. She essentially said, well it’s in litigation and the lawyers won’t let us talk about what happened, but if we could we would tell you the other side of the story…

She also had the chutzpah to say that once they took the “hard decision” to shut down the new kidney transplant unit they did that part (the transferring patients back to the UCSF and UC Davis lists) very well. The rest of her talk was all about how only a non-profit organization had the correct mission for health care. I wasn’t exactly impressed—particularly as most of the issue is about the relationship with the decidedly for-profit Permanente Federation from which nothing has been heard about the kidney fiasco.

Letting the lawyers tell them what to do is rank stupidity. KP needs to prove that a) it does the right thing, and b) if it has screwed up that it’s going to transparently find out why and get it right the next time. At the time I called for a full public inquiry in which KP put a reputable outsider in charge of the investigation and promised to do what s/he recommended. Of course that never happened.

Buying off Merlin doesn’t exactly given a great assurance that next time they’re going to do better. And if they don’t state their case, their haters will do it for them.

Livongo’s Post Ad Banner 728*90

Categories: Uncategorized

Tagged as:

4
Leave a Reply

4 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
4 Comment authors
kpmemberSBDJohn FembupAnonymous Recent comment authors
newest oldest most voted
kpmember
Guest
kpmember

While I’m distressed at how poorly Kaiser has come across re the kidney transplant scandal I’m hopeful that public attention to what happened there (and re other transplant programs in the state) will not flag. Despite Kaiser’s amazing lack of post-scandal transparency, I want to point out that there was major public inquiry into the problems (albeit late and less complete than it could be) by three oversight agencies/organizations: CMS, DMHS and UNOS, all of which produced scathing reports. In addition, at the California Assembly Committee on Health hearing on transplant issues (including the Kaiser situation) held last August in… Read more »

SBD
Guest
SBD

More Kaiser Screwups!!
Laptop Stolen With 22,000 Kaiser Patients’ Data
In yet another instance of laptop theft potentially endangering personal data, Kaiser Permanente is in the process of notifying as many as 22,000 patients of a possible breach of their private medical information.
The personal information was located on a doctor’s laptop computer stolen from the Medical Center in Oakland at the end of last November.
SBD

John Fembup
Guest
John Fembup

Anonymous, your comment on confusion over the behavior of “not-for-profit” institutions vs those “for profit” is right on. Hospitals, physicians, clinics, etc all have bottom lines to generate and protect, whether they be for-profit or not-for-profit and their behaviors reflect that fact. “I believe that many insurance companies will choose to withold treatment from a patieint if it increases their bottom line.” I think you mean to say that many insurance companies will choose to withhold reimbursement . . .” At the same time, it’s pretty clear that there are health care providers who will choose to withhold treatment if… Read more »

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous

A general comment here. Simply being a non profit organization in health care does not absolve it from having conflicts of interest due to profits. I believe that many insurance companies will choose to withold treatment from a patieint if it increases their bottom line. Non profits are non profit in name only, as it is a tax code designation, but they actually do earn a lot of profits.