Uncategorized

PHARMA: Brutal news for Merck

The jury in the first Vioxx trial has found Merck liable for the death of the patient by arrhythmia. Merck had to fight this one as it didn’t even seem to be the kind of heart disease that those people who did get heart disease in the VIGOR and other studies died from.  But they lost, and the jury awarded $253.4m.  Where they got the .4 from I’m not sure, but that’s a hell of a lot of punitive damages.  Guess that "Dodgeball" memo was pretty expensive in the end.

So if you play out the math there are an alleged 56,000 deaths from Vioxx. So if every 4 death’s costs Merck  $1 billion, then they owe some 14 trillion dollars.  That somewhat exceeds the gross national income of the country, so perhaps this amount might be reduced on appeal!

Mrk1yr But either way the recovery that Merck stock’s had since Vioxx was pulled last year is absolutely over for now. And it’ll probably be headed lower than today’s close (as usual wish that I’d bought some put options as they were expiring today!)

Here’s today’s action. Mrktoday Not exactly pretty.

Livongo’s Post Ad Banner 728*90

Categories: Uncategorized

Tagged as: ,

7
Leave a Reply

7 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
4 Comment authors
theorajonesRon Greinermattgadfly Recent comment authors
newest oldest most voted
gadfly
Guest
gadfly

//what Merck themselves estimated they’d earn by lying//
Thank you so much for putting it those words!

theorajones
Guest

They’re punitive damages. They are intended NOT to compensate the victim for having suffered, but to punish the company for lying. In this case, the jury apparently chose to punish Merck by the amount Merck estimated it would earn in profits by refusing to label the drug as heart-dangerous. You can consider the sum outrageous, but it’s what Merck themselves estimated they’d earn by lying. The jury simply said “well, ya should have told the truth. As punishment, we’re taking the money you earned by lying.” I think that’s perfectly defensible. Merck doesn’t have to raise its prices to avoid… Read more »

gadfly
Guest
gadfly

I don’t think such awards are stupid: corporations don’t have an incentive to change for anything less than large numbers. I don’t think of these sorts of awards as any sort of compensation (after all, what can compensate for the loss of a loved one or life-changing disability), but rather as the only way society can convince corporations that lying, stonewalling, and generally treating “people who don’t matter” poorly is a bad, bad, bad idea. When the average person on the streets gets on the corporate side and starts decrying large punitive damages, they are shooting themselves in the foot.… Read more »

Ron Greiner
Guest
Ron Greiner

Sorry, Warren Buffett makes “over” $10 million per year.

Ron Greiner
Guest
Ron Greiner

This is crazy. A couple just got a $15 million award because the doctor could not save their child with a really rare disorder when they arrived at the ER. The doctor only had a couple of hours and he couldn’t figure out what was wrong. But this award is a perfect example of stupidity. Now the cost of all Rx will have to go up to accumulate funds for potential lawsuits. All Rx can be dangerous. Same as any surgery. We should have some limit on liability on each dead person caused by a medical mistake, say $10 million,… Read more »

matt
Guest
matt

Wasn’t the Bush administration pushing to shield drug markers from liability for ANYTHING that the FDA approves? Tort reform will certainly have a hand in ensuring that the will of the jury won’t be realized in this case: “The award…is likely to be drastically reduced to no more than $26.1 million because Texas law caps punitive damages…The jury, which voted 10-2 in favor of Ernst, awarded $450,000 in economic damages for Robert Ernst’s lost pay, $24 million for mental anguish and loss of companionship and $229 million in punitive damages… But state law caps punitive damages at twice the amount… Read more »

gadfly
Guest
gadfly

Victims triumph against Dodgeball, woo hoo!!!!
Now if only corporations would get the message that plain dealing and an apology is ultimately cheaper than Cover Ups and Issues Management.