By OWEN TRIPP

Move over, GLP-1s. This year the healthcare spotlight is on alternative plan design. Alternative health plans offer cost transparency and a consumer-friendly shopping experience. But can the capabilities under the hood deliver on quality and value? Though it may not sound buzzworthy, it has the potential to trigger a seismic shift in the commercial insurance market.
After years of disappointing returns and unmet promises from traditional insurance models, innovators and big-name insurers themselves are doubling down on alternative plans aimed at reducing healthcare costs through preferred care pathways with transparent pricing. Though these plans come in many flavors, common features include tiered networks, variable copays, care steerage, and an emphasis on primary and virtual care — often packaged in a digital-first (and AI-powered) “shopping” experience.
Alternative plans seem like a win-win. For consumers struggling with surprise bills and medical debt, replacing confusing deductibles and coinsurance with predictable copays offers much-needed peace of mind. For employers facing the highest increase in healthcare costs in 15 years, getting their workforce on a trusted path to quality feels like a sure bet.
There’s a catch, though: Alternative plans won’t help much if they lead people to the same old, fragmented healthcare experience. Innovative cost-sharing and a slick front-end experience must be backed by high-quality clinical care, dynamic population health management, and personalized engagement that represent a significant upgrade from what’s been delivered to date.
Otherwise, signing up for an alternative plan will be a lot like buying a shiny new smartphone, only to discover that its operating system only supports a handful of outdated apps.
Alternative plans: what must be under the hood?
While cost transparency and a streamlined shopping experience offer immediate benefits to consumers, it’s the deeper capabilities and levers under the hood of alternative plans that will drive long-term value and create an alternative model worth embracing.
1. A primary care-led integrated care model
Most insurer-led alternative plans are built on top of existing care delivery networks (and existing provider contracts), often leading people to well-worn pathways and settings, including those that have produced status-quo outcomes for people and minimal cost improvement for employers.
Alternative plans need to create new dynamics around primary care, removing access barriers, creating flexibility and incentives, and repositioning expectations for provider interactions. Simply doing more of the same is inadequate. A true primary care-led plan is one that creates new channels and opportunities, dedicates time for immersive one-to-one discovery, and empowers physicians to lead people to quality across the network based on individual needs — supported by data, technology, and system-wide connections.
Continue reading…