
By EMANUEL SARKEES
Most people assume that when they need a doctor, a doctor will be available. That assumption is getting harder to hold onto. Right now, more than 83 million Americans live in highlighted Health Professional Shortage Areas, which is the government’s official notice that where they live does not have enough physicians to meet basic healthcare demand. That is not a projection of something yet to come. It is the situation today, and the numbers are moving in the wrong direction.
The Association of American Medical Colleges projects the United States will face a shortage of up to 86,000 physicians by 2036. The National Center for Health Workforce Analysis puts it even higher, projecting a shortage of 124,180 physicians by 2027 and 187,130 by 2037. The two organizations use different methods but they land in the same place. The country is training, retaining, and deploying far fewer physicians than its growing and aging population needs.
What makes this worth paying attention to right now is not just the size of the problem. It is the fact that this shortage was not some unavoidable outcome. It was built, step by step, and then never was corrected before the damage became permanent.
How the System Built This Problem
The most important driver that most people have never heard of is the residency cap. In 1997, Congress froze the number of Medicare funded graduate medical education positions, which are the residency slots that medical school graduates need to complete before they can practice independently. The system largely preserved the existing distribution of residency positions, which also resulted in preserving an imbalance in the physician workforce. Adding more residency positions does not guarantee that new physicians will enter the primary care specialties or communities where they are actually needed. The result is not a shortage of physicians, but a mismatch between the specialties being trained and what types of physicians the country needs. Medical school enrollment has grown since then. Residency slots have not kept pace. The result is a bottleneck where qualified graduates cannot finish their training because there are not enough funded positions available. Without more residency funding, the final step in the physician training stays limited no matter how many students start medical school.
Medical debt makes the problem worse in a way that directly shapes where physicians end up practicing. The average medical school graduate carries more than $216,000 in student loan debt by the time they finish their education. By the time residency and fellowship training wraps up, which can be six to eight years later, that number has often grown. When a new physician is carrying a quarter million dollars in debt, the decision about where to practice is not made on the factor of where patients need the most help. It is made for the reimbursement system where primary care physicians earn significantly less than procedural specialists, and where rural practices operate on margins that make competitive salaries hard to offer. This is not a flaw in individual physicians. It is math, and the system sets it up this way.
Burnout is the third piece to the puzzle.
Continue reading…