Categories

Tag: Chris Denoia

Australia’s Prisoners’ Dilemma: Incentives Matter in Health Care


The shortcomings of the Fee For Service (FFS) model are widely known.

During the 1800s, the British empire shipped prisoners to newly formed penal colonies in Australia (technically, these were British prisoners, but that doesn’t make a catchy title).  Ship captains were compensated for each prisoner who boarded the ship.  The financial incentive ruled over decency, each captain stuffed as many prisoners on to the ship as it could handle.  Of course, the prisoner survival rate lingered at a precarious 50%, while those who managed to survive the journey often arrived beaten, sick or starving.

Attempts were made to improve the survival rates, through what might be considered early wellness programs.  Captains were mandated to bring citrus to combat scurvy, a 19th century wellness program.  Doctors were required on each ship carrying prisoners, improved access ala concierge medicine.  I’m sure someone may have proposed it’s the prisoners responsibility to survive the trip and they ought to engage in their own survival.  Nevertheless, requiring lemons and limes and placing physicians on the ships proved equally ineffective.

In 1862, economist Edwin Chadwick suggested a change to the incentive structure.  Ship captains were no longer compensated for each prisoner who boarded in England, but, instead, received payment for every living prisoner who got off the ship in Australia.  The first pay for outcomes program in healthcare.  The survival rate on ensuing trips jumped from 50% to 98%.

The moral of the story is that incentives matter.

  • Primary care physicians are the ship captains of the 21st century.
  • American patients are prisoners of the US healthcare system.
  • Misaligned incentives are the root cause for what ails the system.

Christopher DeNoia is the Vice President of Business Development at Amplify Health, where this post originally appeared.

Registration

Forgotten Password?