Starting this month and continuing for the next year or so, I’ll be presenting a standard talk to physician audiences entitled “Confessions of a Physician EMR Champion,” subtitled “A Conversation with American Physicians About How to Save Medicine in the Age of Information.”
The broad message is that, to be successful, the adoption of health IT by physicians, nurses, and staff must extend communication and health data exchange beyond the narrow confines inside the four walls of their practice. Health IT needs to empower all providers to act as effective members of a team which includes the patient, medical home, specialists, and ancillary service providers such as pharmacists and lab technicians.
My “confession” is that for several years I led a team effort by the American Academy of Family Physicians, its state chapters, and its members, to promote adoption of electronic medical records, or EMR software systems. Between 2003 and 2007, the percentage of the AAFP’s active membership of 60,000 doctors who utilize an EMR from a commercial vendor in their practices jumped from about 10 percent to almost 50 percent. The overwhelming majority of the doctors in these practices consider this a good thing, and would never go back to paper systems. The accumulated knowledge and experience about EMRs among the AAFP’s membership is unparalleled.
But EMRs are not enough, as I’ve come to appreciate. Most EMR software systems create digital versions of paper documents, which can be accessed by physicians from almost anywhere. Certainly, the majority of EMRs help assure the accuracy of diagnostic coding and capture these better for billing Medicare or health plans, which adds revenue to many practices that have under-coded in the past. Workflow and internal communications are also often enhanced by some EMRs, especially those that permit e-Prescribing to be done electronically thereby eliminating phone calls and faxes that irritate both waiting patients and busy practice staff.
What I once thought was the end game, however, is really only the starting line. This is because most of the commercially available EMRs, including those that are “certified,” focus on what is good for the doctors and the well-being of their medical practices, but do not yet support the capabilities required to assist patients and doctors to collaborate and make better decisions. Neither do they help manage and coordinate care across a community of providers in different settings or reduce the costs of unnecessary emergency room visits, repeated lab tests, or preventable hospitalizations.
Further, they have very limited ability or commitment to capturing and transmitting the data on a population of patients that would permit improvement in quality, safety, and efficiency to proceed systematically in a community, region or state. And perhaps worst of all, many EMR vendors have resisted the call to make their software capable of exporting and importing a standard set of summary personal health data in computable format such as the Continuity of Care Record, CCR, xml standard. This means that for all practical purposes most EMRs remain “islands of data” that can’t connect even with the archipelago of data in their communities, not to mention the continents of data elsewhere.
I don’t want to blame the doctors or the vendors for this unfortunate state of affairs. Our training teaches us that the quality of medical care relies on the high professional standards of individual physicians, and holds that individual doctors ought to be accountable for excellence.
This has helped to create a health care system in which most patient visits are to small practices with four or fewer doctors. These stand-alone small businesses treasure their autonomy, and are often unwilling and unable to approach the acquisition and use of health IT unless there is an absolute focus on the narrow objectives of the professionals inside their particular small group. EMR vendors have perforce had to follow the same perceptual template, and to customize “stand alone” features and functions on the basis of what group A wants and needs, even if group B in the next county over has very different priorities for feature and function sets.
Believe me, I have a lot of respect for the tolerance and good will of EMR software developers in this domain: the fickleness and variability of their doctor customers tends to be crazy-making. Physicians, for their part, have had precious few opportunities to change their behavior, given the reluctance of health plans and Medicare to stop rewarding procedural throughput over coordination and management of disease. (See Klepper and Kibbe, Oct. 30 THCB post.)
In my Confessions talk, what I am now recommending to physicians, their office managers, and their business partners is that their health IT deployments should no longer be vendor-driven, nor should they be limited to what works best inside the individual practice. Instead, their health IT should be aligned with a business and clinical re-organization strategy that places a much higher value than heretofore on team-based care and management programs involving health data exchange. My message is that the best uses of health IT are those that support participatory medicine, reduce costs, make care more convenient, and close the “collaboration gap” between doctors and their patients in much the same way that online banking and online airline reservation systems have done. I’m encouraging patient portals, community health data exchanges, shared clinical data collection, and intelligent online tools from Health 2.0.
This is not an easy message to sell, I’ll grant you that. The idea of becoming a “virtual Kaiser” gets a lot of pushback from physicians who understand that when patients, physicians, and hospitals are all completely integrated into a single organization it makes business sense to invest in health IT that can prevent hospitalization and which can offer non-visit care such as e-consultations. They are right to protest that their painful reality is that they’re NOT organized in this integrated manner, and that becoming more efficient to the “system” through health IT purchases may actually mean money is taken out of their own practices’ pockets. They see their predicament as “lose-lose” until their cost-saving investments in health IT don’t all go towards savings to the health plans or to Medicare, and until some of those savings return to the practice as revenue that can fund the capital expense associated with health IT.
But change is on the wing, I tell them. No one — not employers, consumers, patients, nor the government — can tolerate disorganized care forever. And everyone seems to recognize that we need to find ways to enhance the organization of care so that cost savings can be achieved and health care dollars are not wasted.
It won’t be easy. But the idea of health IT deployment for its own sake is going out of fashion. In a future blog post, I’ll provide examples of the way health IT can be deployed in medical practices to enhance the capabilities of the Connected Medical Home, and how this just might turn into a “win-win” for doctors and their patients, provided policies under the new Obama administration encourage new payment mechanisms to reward quality, continuity, and efficiency. I confess that I should have seen this earlier!
David C. Kibbe MD MBA is a Family Physician and Senior Advisor to the American Academy of Family Physicians who consults on healthcare professional and consumer technologies.
Categories: Uncategorized

I’ve read it from other site. Follow up, is it better to have the developers bring it to you for you to know how to use it easier because others just buy one and then complain.
-nj
Great blog. Dr. Kibbe is going in the right direction. I wish him success. The current buzzword in medicine is evidence based medicine. We should apply the same to our use of computers etc in medicine. I don’t believe that I have seen a single article demonstrate with real world data that computers and EMR’s are saving lives. Let’s get the data before we spend a few billion dollars and find we have to do it all over again.
Very interesting post. Using a completely integrated solution which combines EMR and practice management would seem to be the best way for a new practice to start so that there are no “islands of data.”
Can anybody show me objective, reproducible, evidence that an EMR actually SAVES money? – remember, I’m not talking about making more information more available – I means evidence that would persuade a hard nosed accountant that it was a good FINANCIAL decision. pLEASE REPLY VIA EMAIL – CVALLEN@POL.NET – CV ALLEN M.D.
MEDICAL RECORD AWARENESS: REQUESTING AND EXAMINING YOUR MEDICAL RECORD IS THE FIRST STEP IN COMMUNICATING WITH YOUR PHYSICIAN!
Teacher inspired by her students to raise awareness about medical record errors. Teacher/Entrepreneur Eunita Winkey and founder of ATWINDS Foundation, Inc. (A Teacher’s Work Is Never Done Services) will host and moderate a Health Care Community Discussion conference call on Medical Record Awareness. She is a victim and survivor of medical record errors. She believes that in order to save lives and decrease medical cost, electronic medical records should be mandatory just as electronic credit records. What do you think is more important medical records or credit records? Do you know what’s in your medical records? To join the Health Care Community Discussion visit http://www.atwindsfoundation.org for the conference call schedule and rules.
This is my story what’s yours!
At some point in our lives, each one of us will visit a physician and put our lives in the physician’s hands. However, the stakes are high in the medical profession because misdiagnosed illnesses or incorrect medical information could cause grave consequences. Health care professionals should be held at the highest possible standards since medical errors can seriously affect the decisions that are made regarding our health, possibly resulting in irreversible health results or even death. Errors made by healthcare professionals are often swept under the rug, even when serious damages are the result. As an educator, it is my responsibility to educate and be an advocate for our communities by sharing my medical record story. If I had been educated on the importance of requesting my medical records during my treatments, I would not have experienced such a tragic outcome of a total hysterectomy and suffered the emotional and physical stress I have had to endure since my hysterectomy. In 1998 at the age of 39, I was beginning a new life with a second marriage. My husband and I did not have children and anxiously anticipated starting a family. However, that anticipation was shattered in the wink of an eye by a life-altering experience with an in vitro fertilization (IVF) physician and obstetrics-gynecologist (Ob/Gyn). The treating IVF physician visited me during my consultation at the Ob/Gyn’s office. I felt very special when the physician traveled to see me for an appointment, and I was also relieved by the referral to the IVF medical center. However, I later learned that it was unethical for the Ob/Gyn to refer me to his IVF physician-friend. Always be cautious when accepting a referral from another physician. Conduct your own research by using the Internet or get referrals from family members or friends. Out of 15 doctor visits, my name was misspelled 10 times, e.g., my first and last name were completely misspelled—not just a simple typo. Treatments and other information were also incorrectly recorded in the Ob/Gyn’s notes, e.g., treatments that I requested were never noted. In addition, the hospital that performed my surgery had another person’s name listed on my record, instead of mine. My medical records also revealed that the Ob/Gyn had held a conference with me prior to my hysterectomy concerning the complications and side effects of the surgery, but that was untrue since there had been no such discussion with him or anyone else. A review of the Ob/Gyn’s records left me speechless, and it did not dawn on me until later that the IVF physician’s notes were also false. On my husband’s semen profile, the andrologist documented that his semen analysis was completed at 10:00 a.m. on May 10, 1998. However, our first appointment was not until May 11, 1998, which is the date my husband’s semen sample was taken. My husband and I are still wondering what happened to his semen sample since that information was not documented in the medical record. In 1997 at age 38, I started trying to conceive a child by taking Clomid fertility drugs. However, in 1999, the IVF physician signed a report stating that I was 49 years old, which was 10 years older than my correct age of 39. No date of birth was listed on the report to bring attention to the error. In addition, the IVF physician stated that I had previously taken two cycles of Clomid treatments in 1987. This was a false statement since I did not begin taking Clomid treatments until 1997. My chances of becoming a mother at 39 would have obviously been greater than at age 49. Unfortunately, I did not learn of this error until 3 years later. When the IVF physician reported that the first fertility treatment had failed, I requested a second fertility treatment but was immediately turned down due to my age, which was incorrectly recorded. The failed fertility treatment was not noted in my medical records. However, the Ob/Gyn records indicated that the IVF physician had recommended a total hysterectomy, but the recommendation was made 3 months before I began the IVF treatments. As a result of the 10-year error in my age and other false statements noted in my medical records, I was given a total hysterectomy (removal of my uterus, cervix, both ovaries, and fallopian tubes) that left me scarred for life. I immediately became very depressed and was prescribed Paxil for my depression. Following the surgery, my body was immediately thrown into full-blown menopause without any prior discussion regarding these devastating side effects. For the first 2 years, I only slept about 2 hours each night due to the severe hot flashes and night sweats that kept me awake. For the past 6 years, some areas of my body are numb and there is no feeling, even when I pinch myself. In addition, the nerves in my body are damaged due to the absence of my female organs and, at times, my life seems very foggy. Some of the other side effects experienced by myself and other women who have had this surgery are loss of sexual desire and arousal sensation, joint and muscle pain, painful intercourse, displacement of bladder (which may cause incontinence or other bladder problems), bowel problems, nerve damage, high blood pressure, varied body odor, loss of short-term memory, personality changes, and irritability. Hysterectomy side effects are life long, and no treatment or drugs can replace ovarian or uterine hormones. My life and marriage have been under great stress since my hysterectomy. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC], “Hysterectomy is the second most common surgical procedure among women of reproductive age and will affect more than a quarter of all U.S. women by the time they reach the age of 60.” The CDC also reported that approximately 600,000 women undergo a hysterectomy in the United States each year at an estimated annual cost of over $5 billion. Fifty-five percent of the hysterectomies performed are on women between the ages of 35 and 49. Women between the ages of 40 and 45 are at the highest risk of undergoing hysterectomy, while women ages 15 to 24 have the lowest risk. The American College of Obstetrics and Gynecology is currently entrenched in a controversy stemming from the recent rise in the number of women under age 35 who are undergoing hysterectomies. Many of these women are reporting a variety of problems including early menopause, decreased sexual function, and other medical and psychological problems. There are other alternatives to hysterectomy, depending on the nature of the problem and the age of the patient. Even though many physicians elect surgery, this should only be used a last resort. The three most common conditions associated with hysterectomy are fibroid tumors, endometriosis, and uterine prolapse. Cervical displasia and menstrual disturbances are the most common reasons for hysterectomy in women under age 30. Women ages 30 to 34 most often undergo hysterectomy due to endometriosis, while the most common reason for hysterectomy among women ages 35 to 54 is fibroid tumors. In women ages 55 and older, uterine prolapse and cancer are the most common reasons for hysterectomy. If a woman suffers from fibroids or myomas, the physician should consider the size of the lesion and determine whether or not it is causing problems for the patient. Many times, doctors opt to “watch” the fibroid for changes and evaluate the patient annually instead of performing surgery. If the fibroid is one of the 5% that cause intrauterine bleeding and severe menstrual pain, there are also ways to treat it aggressively without resorting to hysterectomy. These include D&C or endometrial oblation, where the lining of the uterus is literally scraped, or uterine artery embolization, where the blood flow into the fibroid is severed in order to stop its growth. Another option to consider in the case of fibroids is the use of the drug Luperon, which stunts the growth of the lesion. Fibroids are highly sensitive to estrogen and progesterone, and they are literally “fed” by these hormones. During the onset of menopause, however, the hormone levels drop sharply and, in most cases, the
fibroids will stop growing. Following a review of my medical records by a hysterectomy expert, it was determined that I did not have a severe case of endometriosis or large fibroids as was documented in my medical records, thus, my hysterectomy surgery was totally unnecessary. Although the cost of the IVF treatment was $16,000 for one 6-week cycle, my medical insurance provided me with a 6-month referral, which would have covered two more cycle treatments. However, due to the serious medical record errors, the IVF physician refused to give me the opportunity to try and procreate. Citizen must request copies of your medical records from all health care providers every 6 months or annually because you have a legal right to all of your medical information. Once you receive your medical records, be sure to examine them for accuracy and question any medical inaccuracy.
10 Ways To Make Sure Your Medical Records Are Accurate Make sure you request all medical records from doctors, make several copies of all medical records and read each line of your medical records carefully.
· Make sure you examine all of your medical records with the aid of a medical dictionary, drug or pill book. As you read your medical report highlight what you do not understand.
· Make sure that all names, ages, date of births, social security and patient identification numbers are correct and listed.
· Make sure that all names, ages, date of births, social security and patient identification numbers are correct and listed.
· Make sure that all names, ages, date of births, social security and patient identification numbers are correct and listed. Make sure all dates and time of services are noted and correct.
· Make sure you compare all reports for accuracy from your doctor office, hospital, lab, and pathology.
· Make sure all doctors and other healthcare staff signatures are on your reports.
· Make sure that all conversations between you and your doctor are accurate to the best of your knowledge.
· Make sure all treatment options, medications, and side effects are noted.
· Make sure you research all medical terms, illness, and treatments using the Internet or medical manuals.
· Make sure you have other non-bias experts examine your medical records.
MEDICAL RECORD AWARENESS: REQUESTING AND EXAMINING YOUR MEDICAL RECORD IS THE FIRST STEP IN COMMUNICATING WITH YOUR PHYSICIAN!
Teacher inspired by her students to raise awareness about medical record errors. Teacher/Entrepreneur Eunita Winkey and founder of ATWINDS Foundation, Inc. (A Teacher’s Work Is Never Done Services) will host and moderate a Health Care Community Discussion conference call on Medical Record Awareness. She is a victim and survivor of medical record errors. She believes that in order to save lives and decrease medical cost, electronic medical records should be mandatory just as electronic credit records. What do you think is more important medical records or credit records? Do you know what’s in your medical records? To join the Health Care Community Discussion visit http://www.atwindsfoundation.org for the conference call schedule and rules.
This is my story what’s yours!
At some point in our lives, each one of us will visit a physician and put our lives in the physician’s hands. However, the stakes are high in the medical profession because misdiagnosed illnesses or incorrect medical information could cause grave consequences. Health care professionals should be held at the highest possible standards since medical errors can seriously affect the decisions that are made regarding our health, possibly resulting in irreversible health results or even death. Errors made by healthcare professionals are often swept under the rug, even when serious damages are the result. As an educator, it is my responsibility to educate and be an advocate for our communities by sharing my medical record story. If I had been educated on the importance of requesting my medical records during my treatments, I would not have experienced such a tragic outcome of a total hysterectomy and suffered the emotional and physical stress I have had to endure since my hysterectomy. In 1998 at the age of 39, I was beginning a new life with a second marriage. My husband and I did not have children and anxiously anticipated starting a family. However, that anticipation was shattered in the wink of an eye by a life-altering experience with an in vitro fertilization (IVF) physician and obstetrics-gynecologist (Ob/Gyn). The treating IVF physician visited me during my consultation at the Ob/Gyn’s office. I felt very special when the physician traveled to see me for an appointment, and I was also relieved by the referral to the IVF medical center. However, I later learned that it was unethical for the Ob/Gyn to refer me to his IVF physician-friend. Always be cautious when accepting a referral from another physician. Conduct your own research by using the Internet or get referrals from family members or friends. Out of 15 doctor visits, my name was misspelled 10 times, e.g., my first and last name were completely misspelled—not just a simple typo. Treatments and other information were also incorrectly recorded in the Ob/Gyn’s notes, e.g., treatments that I requested were never noted. In addition, the hospital that performed my surgery had another person’s name listed on my record, instead of mine. My medical records also revealed that the Ob/Gyn had held a conference with me prior to my hysterectomy concerning the complications and side effects of the surgery, but that was untrue since there had been no such discussion with him or anyone else. A review of the Ob/Gyn’s records left me speechless, and it did not dawn on me until later that the IVF physician’s notes were also false. On my husband’s semen profile, the andrologist documented that his semen analysis was completed at 10:00 a.m. on May 10, 1998. However, our first appointment was not until May 11, 1998, which is the date my husband’s semen sample was taken. My husband and I are still wondering what happened to his semen sample since that information was not documented in the medical record. In 1997 at age 38, I started trying to conceive a child by taking Clomid fertility drugs. However, in 1999, the IVF physician signed a report stating that I was 49 years old, which was 10 years older than my correct age of 39. No date of birth was listed on the report to bring attention to the error. In addition, the IVF physician stated that I had previously taken two cycles of Clomid treatments in 1987. This was a false statement since I did not begin taking Clomid treatments until 1997. My chances of becoming a mother at 39 would have obviously been greater than at age 49. Unfortunately, I did not learn of this error until 3 years later. When the IVF physician reported that the first fertility treatment had failed, I requested a second fertility treatment but was immediately turned down due to my age, which was incorrectly recorded. The failed fertility treatment was not noted in my medical records. However, the Ob/Gyn records indicated that the IVF physician had recommended a total hysterectomy, but the recommendation was made 3 months before I began the IVF treatments. As a result of the 10-year error in my age and other false statements noted in my medical records, I was given a total hysterectomy (removal of my uterus, cervix, both ovaries, and fallopian tubes) that left me scarred for life. I immediately became very depressed and was prescribed Paxil for my depression. Following the surgery, my body was immediately thrown into full-blown menopause without any prior discussion regarding these devastating side effects. For the first 2 years, I only slept about 2 hours each night due to the severe hot flashes and night sweats that kept me awake. For the past 6 years, some areas of my body are numb and there is no feeling, even when I pinch myself. In addition, the nerves in my body are damaged due to the absence of my female organs and, at times, my life seems very foggy. Some of the other side effects experienced by myself and other women who have had this surgery are loss of sexual desire and arousal sensation, joint and muscle pain, painful intercourse, displacement of bladder (which may cause incontinence or other bladder problems), bowel problems, nerve damage, high blood pressure, varied body odor, loss of short-term memory, personality changes, and irritability. Hysterectomy side effects are life long, and no treatment or drugs can replace ovarian or uterine hormones. My life and marriage have been under great stress since my hysterectomy. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC], “Hysterectomy is the second most common surgical procedure among women of reproductive age and will affect more than a quarter of all U.S. women by the time they reach the age of 60.” The CDC also reported that approximately 600,000 women undergo a hysterectomy in the United States each year at an estimated annual cost of over $5 billion. Fifty-five percent of the hysterectomies performed are on women between the ages of 35 and 49. Women between the ages of 40 and 45 are at the highest risk of undergoing hysterectomy, while women ages 15 to 24 have the lowest risk. The American College of Obstetrics and Gynecology is currently entrenched in a controversy stemming from the recent rise in the number of women under age 35 who are undergoing hysterectomies. Many of these women are reporting a variety of problems including early menopause, decreased sexual function, and other medical and psychological problems. There are other alternatives to hysterectomy, depending on the nature of the problem and the age of the patient. Even though many physicians elect surgery, this should only be used a last resort. The three most common conditions associated with hysterectomy are fibroid tumors, endometriosis, and uterine prolapse. Cervical displasia and menstrual disturbances are the most common reasons for hysterectomy in women under age 30. Women ages 30 to 34 most often undergo hysterectomy due to endometriosis, while the most common reason for hysterectomy among women ages 35 to 54 is fibroid tumors. In women ages 55 and older, uterine prolapse and cancer are the most common reasons for hysterectomy. If a woman suffers from fibroids or myomas, the physician should consider the size of the lesion and determine whether or not it is causing problems for the patient. Many times, doctors opt to “watch” the fibroid for changes and evaluate the patient annually instead of performing surgery. If the fibroid is one of the 5% that cause intrauterine bleeding and severe menstrual pain, there are also ways to treat it aggressively without resorting to hysterectomy. These include D&C or endometrial oblation, where the lining of the uterus is literally scraped, or uterine artery embolization, where the blood flow into the fibroid is severed in order to stop its growth. Another option to consider in the case of fibroids is the use of the drug Luperon, which stunts the growth of the lesion. Fibroids are highly sensitive to estrogen and progesterone, and they are literally “fed” by these hormones. During the onset of menopause, however, the hormone levels drop sharply and, in most cases, the
fibroids will stop growing. Following a review of my medical records by a hysterectomy expert, it was determined that I did not have a severe case of endometriosis or large fibroids as was documented in my medical records, thus, my hysterectomy surgery was totally unnecessary. Although the cost of the IVF treatment was $16,000 for one 6-week cycle, my medical insurance provided me with a 6-month referral, which would have covered two more cycle treatments. However, due to the serious medical record errors, the IVF physician refused to give me the opportunity to try and procreate. Citizen must request copies of your medical records from all health care providers every 6 months or annually because you have a legal right to all of your medical information. Once you receive your medical records, be sure to examine them for accuracy and question any medical inaccuracy.
10 Ways To Make Sure Your Medical Records Are Accurate Make sure you request all medical records from doctors, make several copies of all medical records and read each line of your medical records carefully.
· Make sure you examine all of your medical records with the aid of a medical dictionary, drug or pill book. As you read your medical report highlight what you do not understand.
· Make sure that all names, ages, date of births, social security and patient identification numbers are correct and listed.
· Make sure that all names, ages, date of births, social security and patient identification numbers are correct and listed.
· Make sure that all names, ages, date of births, social security and patient identification numbers are correct and listed. Make sure all dates and time of services are noted and correct.
· Make sure you compare all reports for accuracy from your doctor office, hospital, lab, and pathology.
· Make sure all doctors and other healthcare staff signatures are on your reports.
· Make sure that all conversations between you and your doctor are accurate to the best of your knowledge.
· Make sure all treatment options, medications, and side effects are noted.
· Make sure you research all medical terms, illness, and treatments using the Internet or medical manuals.
· Make sure you have other non-bias experts examine your medical records.
David, It is encouraging that your perspective on the role of electronic medical records in the context of small physician practices is based on widespread innovation in the American Academy of Family Physicians. This experience and your comments emphasize the importance of changing the model of health care to create a new team model including the patient. Let’s ask that Obama and Daschle set up guideposts and standards that encourage effective change in health delivery, going far beyond new software systems that record information only to support traditional behavior.
Dr. Kibbe, I’m an admitted babe in the woods here with tons to learn but I have to tell you that your use of the phrase “better health care” seems vague and somewhat hackneyed, akin to the idea of “improving health”. (Noble but not highly quantifiable.)
My Family Medicine husband has, off the cuff, these main problems:
1) a reimbursement system tilted towards the doc who can see plenty of patients rapidly;
2) a generally older, high complexity patient base with multiple problems (which he likes and does well with) that generally do not fit into a rapid visit format;
3) A documentation framework that isn’t serving him. He uses a mix of dictation and paper templates that leaves him constantly behind. (An experiement in EMR about 5 years ago initiated by a partner was totally disastrous and not time saving.) He needs a documentation system that is responsive to his individual style and recognizes the unpredictable nature of family medicine visits. And that does not typically involve him keyboarding in anything except perhaps unique documentation of the points of discussion and recommendations and referrals.
4) Ideally this system would gin out some kind of summary sheet of the visit, concerns and recommendations when a referral was needed that would integrate some PMH, current meds and problems, and perhaps HPI of the reason for this visit. This would promote timely information exchange with a referred specialist.
5) It would facilitate billing and maximizing his billing
6) It would allow him to input data into a PDA/Treo for charging hospital visits and it would be real time and go directly to his billing department.
7) It would output information to the patient that would summarize the visit and reiterate patient recommendations and medication instructions.
8) I guess it would electronically transmmit prescriptions.
But it doesn’t seem like systems are organic and they don’t seem to really answer the core problem: A quick and easy to use documentatios system that reflects the unique nature of Family Medicine visits and their range from the acute sinusitis to the follow-up of the multi-system impaired elederly patient. I personally think that this is the core thing that wears my husband out. And I think that if this nut were cracked, other issues would soon follow.
So, I realize my basic newbie-ness here. What do you mean succintly when you say “improve patient care”. There may be some summary document you’ve already published that says this…
I’ve been reading Dr. Bean’s comments and others and while I realize that data is a much more trendy phrase, most doctors (aside from lab data) don’t deal so much in data as they do information. When you integrate knowledge about a person, their family, their community, their wishes, their disease state and it’s particular point of progression and their goals for their health, you really don’t come away with that many data points. Often with elderly patients that my husband sees, he’s dealing with, say a person who is on a research based medicine protocol designed to maximize cardiac function BUT the crux issue for the patient is they cannot afford OR tolerate OR feel as well as they want to on that regimen. If your outcome measurse is blood pressure or CRP or cardiac ejection fraction, the patient may “worsen” based on med changes but the patient may subjectively feel better and be willing to make the trade-off.
Just a mish-mash of thoughts. This is a fascinating blog.
Got a quick update here: Implantable RFID chips are already in use at some major hospitals. They are harmless, and just make sure the patient and his data set are in the right place at the right time so nobody gets lost and nobody loses the wrong kidney.
Imagine a chip that can be a permanent implant which contains all the patient’s records and which is updated with all lab, diagnostic testing, and visits with a doctor at the time they occur. It is almost here, and it will be the greatest thing for doctors. They wouldn’t need to chart anymore because it would all be stored in the patient. Nobody would waste hours of staff time faxing, e-mailing, and calling for old records.
Every decision and note would be permanently etched in the memory chip. (Every mistake too, so lawyers will be happy).
Patients could upload claims from a computer terminal to the government or to big insurance companies or their employers, or whoever else has access to this data.
It could also surreptitiously record the patient’s travel habits, purchasing habits, and lifestyle habits. ( But hey, who would do such a thing?)
Moving this thread over to Part 2 of the Confessions blog…
https://thehealthcareblog.com/the_health_care_blog/2008/11/confessions-of.html
DCK
All: Let’s move the conversation over to Part 2 of this blog, which perhaps some people missed all together. I’ll respond to Christine and to Cyril here: https://thehealthcareblog.com/the_health_care_blog/2008/12/confessions-of.html#more
Thanks, DCK
Thanks to David, Ted, Cyril and all. I think of this as The Great Kibbe Debate, the gift that keeps on giving, at least to the non-specialist 🙂
Every time I tune in, I learn more.
And thanks, Ted and I are in contact. And David, I would like to hear how you altered your TN talk, if at all, after this blog, and if anything on this post helped you reach that audience more effectively.
Or, if the political and economic news just obviated half of these issues.
Many of the issues discussed in this blog are addressed in our Healthcare IT Public Policy White Paper which can be found in the News section at http://www.amcisnetwork.com . The white paper is written from the vantage point of innovative EMR companies that want to improve physician adoption in a cost-effective manner with minimal interference in the private market. I hope that you have a chance to review it and see how the recommendations in the white paper could benefit our nations healthcare system.
Thanks, Ted. And thanks, Christine. I’m certainly not an expert on the health IT systems at Kaiser, either those primarily for physician and staff use, or those offered to patients as a PHR. But I hope that Christine will take up the kind offer from Ted, and meet with him to discuss how to improve it. This is extraordinarily generous as an offer, and I know Ted to be a sincere person in all respects.
Part 2 of Confessions tomorrow. DCK
Christine,
Great comment about transparency. I hope you will keep expecting it from your health care system – all stakeholders. I will, too.
On that note, I want to also say that the comment about Kaiser Permanente’s electronic health record is not reflective of my experience at all, and I’ve known the KP HealthConnect team since it was formed, in 2003.
I have a little bit of extra experience recently because I’ve actually been reviewing all of the data about this project in the work I am doing right now, and it’s very clear that patient/member experience is front and center in the way the system is designed, and the way its value is measured.
As I mentioned previously, I am beginning to post information about Kaiser Permanente and the KP HealthConnect project on my blog. A presentation I gave covering the patient-access side of things is here.
Maybe there are other questions, concerns, or thoughts that people have about the Kaiser Permanente HealthConnect project, so here’s my offer:
Feel free to send any question to me via the contact form on my blog:
http://www.tedeytan.com/contact
…and I will either get you the information you are looking for or connect you to a KP expert who will.
If you are in or near a region with a Kaiser Permanente medical office, I will work to connect you with an expert locally, as well.
The goal is not to show perfection – we want to be accountable to improve the things that need to be improved, and that happens best when everyone has accurate information.
I’m actually spending some focused time with the team this week, and will be happy to deliver the feedback/questions, so send away.
With respect,
Ted
(Ted Eytan, MD, The Permanente Federation)
Then (to clarify my own thinking), the question is not whether all stakeholders’ interests are represented in your discussion, but the difference between their relative financial power and the actual weight one gives their specific interests in finding an IT solution.
Kaiser chose an IT system, it appears, where the primary focus was billing and coding, excluding the patients, their customers, almost entirely. You can’t pay lip service to patients and then “forget” their existence while expecting a viable outcome.
Again, patient access to records creates transparency. This is the first step in identifying error, demanding accountability, rectifying deceptive or inefficient practices, and correcting an unhealthy balance of power.
Well, Christine, I don’t think I’m leaving anyone out. DCK
But David, de facto you’ve already segmented out distinct players in this debate — physicians and tech companies — and mainly forgotten two others, patients and insurance companies.
If the US healthcare system were a medival kingdom, that would be like leaving serfs and the Privy Council out of a debate on economic transformation. Some of the latter, you might note, are already quite “servantlike” in their position — I don’t think its the patients who need lessons in humility, nor nurses, come to think of it — while others are so powerful they can afford invisibility.
Given way this debate has unfolded, if you leave insurance companies out of the equation, meaning you demand no accountability, I would guess this leaves them laughing all the way to the bank.
Christine: There are a lot of problems with the current health plan system in the US. Too many plans, too many benefits programs, too much paper work, too little reward for efficiency and quality….etc. But it’s probably not helpful to single out one component of this dysfunctional set of systems to place most of the blame upon. Patients, doctors, hospitals, health plans, the feds, the device companies, etc. etc. all need to change and move from the death spiral-cum-speculative bubble-cum-hardcore denial scenario that we’re all in, and which Esther Dyson has called a “calcified hairball.”
I, too, hope that the Obama administration is listening, and that they’re going to be able to shock “the system” back into some reasonable behaviors on the part of all of us. We need a healthy citizenry to face the challenges of the future on this planet. We are all citizens. We are all brothers and sisters, mothers and fathers. We ought to care deeply that health is made available to all within the limits of our resources. We ought to care that people die in dignity and peace when their time has come. We ought to care that our health care professionals — doctors, nurses, health plan CEOs, pharma executives, and device company managers — are not primarily concerned in making deals and getting rich, but are truly servants. Regards, DCK
David,
To make a system work, what kind of political reform do you envision for insurance companies? It seems from the above, that the sticking point (or one) for physicians is that insurance companies are inflexible. Why should taxpayers subsidize innovation while insurance companies extract the same high (and mysterious) level of profit from physicians and patients?
Perhaps the real IT revolution is for the patient-physician nexus to rebel against the headlock that insurance companies have on everyone. As currently envisioned, the insurance-physician nexus is doing a patient lock-out. This frustrates and angers physicians, who can only innovate within very narrow parameters, and increases physician-patient hostility.
Note we hear from everyone on this site BUT insurance companies. Even though members of this tribe must read THCB, apparently none of their reps are jumping forward to defend practices. They don’t seem to be screaming from frustration or complaining about prices or profits.
I hope someone from the Obama administration is listening.
Christine: The VA’s system is of great interest to me. I did some consulting for the VA on its design way back when, and it’s a great system. The problem is that it’s incredibly difficult to replicate in other communities where the health care practices, hospitals, and pharmacies are not owned by a single entity. It is the epitome of a centralized, massively supported health IT architecture. Kaiser has a similar situation and infrastructure, whether one likes it or not.
And, in both the Kaiser and VA there is alignment around payer, provider, and patient interests…or at least there is much greater alignment than in most community settings, where data are isolated and fragmented, almost impossible to aggregate as is done in the VA and Kaiser, and where this fragmentation leads to more care that someone has to pay for. Hence, a vicious cycle that encourages waste and duplication, and not prevention or coordination. And problems of neglect for the patient.
It will be incumbent on the Obama administration to encourage more Kaiser-like and VA-like behaviors in the community-based and independent health care system, perhaps by paying differentially higher amounts to quality health care organizations that can share information, coordinate care, and provide a better and more continuous patient experience. Participatory medicine is going to grow and expand if this happens, because so many people — doctors and consumers alike — are ready for the change. Regards, DCK
So, to sum up for the uninitiated:
Richard has a patient-centered system (PHR) that works for the patient-physician relationship, and allows for patient control-privacy, but doesn’t profit the physician except through greater efficiency, better patient care and interoperability but doesn’t interest the physician-insurance nexus;
Kaiser spent a zillion dollar on a system that is efficient in terms of coding, billing and intra- and perhaps inter-institution communication, but they FORGOT (or deliberately excluded) the patient;
Integrating IT for mid-sized practices which allows for efficient staff use, billing, and physician use but mostly forgets the patient is an experimental hair ball and does not allow for interoperability (meaning ease of referrals, which don’t profit those practices);
The VA, which tracks the patient for life and is the model for the possibilities for a successful single payer system, has IT which works with regard to billing, coding, interoperability and serves the patient’s interest, but is not of much interest to Dr. Kibbe’s project . . .
What’s wrong with this picture?
(and yes, I agree with XRay, that HIPPA is used mainly against the patient; sorta ham handed like No Child Left Behind)
R. Ferreira is correct. The patient must assume some responsibility for his/her own health. When patients call the office for a prescription refill, 90% of the time, they cannot tell you what medication they are on, or what their dosage is. Only a programmable medical chip could manage this information efficiently, and the technology is mature. Mr. Ferreira, please post this link again!
HIPAA was supposed to protect the patient from abuse/ commercialization of their healthcare information. Instead it has resulted in a fearful kneejerk reaction where summer camps have parents filling out HIPAA forms, and hospitals denying critical information to primary care physicians calling about the patients they admitted!
At the same time, I personally have received marketing materials from a competitor pharmaceutical company for a condition which I really do not want publicized!
None of the protection which is promised. Additional penalties and work for everyone involved. That is the typical result of “There Ought to be a Law.”
The problem with many existing systems are:
1. They work only in a Local Area Network (LAN) or Wide Area Network (WAN). This means they work within that particular provider’s system but cannot be accessed by anyone else.
2. They are designed to sustain a specialty need (a hospital environment or a subspecialty of medical practice).
3. They are designed by vendors to store data and are not aimed at the creation of a usable record depending instead on what is input.
What is needed is simply an electronic record that is owned and controlled by the patient and secondarily by the physician. All physicians can input their data and it is accessible to the patient and all other physicians with proper permission by the patient to view the information. It is NOT (emphasized) accessible by any other institution (government or private.
The EMR is owned by the patient and not by any hospital, clinic group, physician, software vendor, other enterprise, be it governmental or private. The processes to accomplish this and the methodologies to assure privacy and control exist.
David
A basic primer w/ issues statement would be good to tie different audiences into the discussion. For many people, the IT angle is the least interesting or the most intimidating
Btw. I just asked my daughter’s ortho surgeon who was best in terms of HIT and she said the VA hands down. Kaiser is good for everyone BUT the patient.
Christine and others: In my Part 2 Confessions blog post, I’m going to articulate 5 capabilities that I think are most important for health IT to provide or enhance in the framework of participatory medicine. I call the health IT that provides or enhances these capabilities “empowering health IT.” While I think that knowing health IT terms is important, I think it’s more important to understand and agree on the tasks and capabilities we’re trying to accomplish or create via some kind of health IT product, service, or application. If we start there, perhaps we’ll have fewer acronyms, or, at least they’ll be more meaningful. 😉 But I’m glad to do a basic primer of IT terms, too, if that will help someone. Regards, DCK
Great discussion! Amazing what one can learn when all sides of a discussion are represented. — except insurance. One senses if the macro problem was solved — the stranglehold insurance has on physicians and patients– the microproblems of tech innovation might disappear.
Insurance has two customers/serfs: physicians and patients. As consumer / participants, neither group is well served . That says something pretty bad about the last eight years of
“free market”/corporate activity in the US.
Two ideas: challenge/invitation to Dr Kibbe to create a primer of basic IT terms, most of which appear here, for posting on thcb and e-patients.net. This is a win-win in that it serves a novice physician audience (present company excepted except me) and it provides patients a portal to enter into the conversation.
Thanks to Malcolm and Ferreira for presenting solutions which work…one upshot of the systems you describe is that of demands reasonable levels of patient literacy. Which is a good thing and accords with the emphasis of the oncoming administration. Literacy.
I sit here each day and read through the comments on this blog and note the number of instances where local area responses are provided (Kaiser and Mayo)and also comments relating to costs (billions of dollars) to implement such a system. Yet in my comment I provided an existing product with full capability and there is no comment back.
The need is now and it would not take ten years to implement nor cost billions of dollars. Insurers have seen the product as have physicians and both want it. It is a universal application of existing technologies without any programming to learn. It is simply point and touch and then read. The information and data is all there and is up-to-date.
Why does there seem to be no interest in such a product?
This is a great discussion. It truly highlights that health care reform will not occur by fixing one thing — but that there are several steps that need to be taken in tandem for true, patient-centered reform to occur.
I work with the Mayo Clinic Health Policy Center — for the past two years, we’ve gathered more than 2,000 stakeholders including patients and patient advocates, health care providers, large and small employers, and representatives from insurance, medical industry and pharma, the government and academia. When these people have gathered, face-to-face, at dozens of events, they have discussed and agreed on four principles (and specific steps to take) to achieve reform: coordinated care, creating value (reducing error, improving patient outcomes, increasing patient satisfaction, focusing on wellness), payment reform, and insurance for all.
Health IT (EMR and PHR) and interoperability is a key component but, as stated earlier, providers also need to learn to collaborate and work together and the payment/reimbursement system must be redesigned to reward that behavior. We need to move away from a fee-for-service model and think about (and pay for) health care that keeps people as well as possible over time. That includes management of chronic illnesses so catastrophic events are prevented, a focus on improving access to and rewarding primary care and preventive care, and making sure that providers are rewarded for delivering good outcomes more efficiently over time.
In April, we will be gathering patients, health care educators at all levels, government groups, and related societies and boards for a Medical Education Reform symposium. The goal is to look at how we educated and train all our health care professionals — and what needs to change to produce a work force that can deliver the kind of health care reform that is needed. I encourage you to check it out on our Web site. And keep the conversation going!
American Medicine is anything but Free Market. Unlike a visit to your auto mechanic, where you pay a skilled laborer for services rendered, you do not pay your doctor.
Your insurance pays your doctor. Your employer pays your insurer ( out of what could be your bigger paycheck). Your employer tries to find the most affordable insurance. Your insurance company makes a profit (and awards tens of millions to its CEO) by taking in your premium and by not paying out claims. Since you must use a doctor contracted by your insurer you are limited to whom you can see, and “taking your business elsewhere” is meaningless. Since your doctor isn’t paid by you, it isn’t hi