Should Doctors Keep Patients’ HIV Status a Secret?

Should Doctors Keep Patients’ HIV Status a Secret?

38
SHARE

At my infectious-diseases clinic in Southeast Washington, I work with some of the city’s most indigent patients. Some don’t have jobs, a home, a car or enough to eat. But recently, I saw a patient whose problem made these issues seem trivial.

Dealing with fatigue, a cough and a fever for several months, this woman in her 40s had been evaluated by four internists. They had tested her for a variety of conditions but not HIV. Each had recommended rest, two prescribed antibiotics, and one suggested an over-the-counter cough medicine. Experiencing no physical relief from these suggestions, the woman had decided to “lay down and die.”

However, after her longtime partner insisted she get medical help, she agreed to go to a hospital emergency room. After a rapid test, which she initially refused because she said she was not at risk for HIV, she learned that she was HIV-positive.

After that ER visit, she brought her partner, whom she credits with saving her life, to my clinic to be tested; she was concerned that she had transmitted the virus to him. He tested positive. About a week later, when he accompanied her to an appointment with me, I asked if he had been seen by a doctor to discuss treatment. He said no and indicated that he wanted to establish care in the clinic.

When I asked if he had ever been on HIV drugs, he gazed at the medication chart and pointed out his previous regimen, a cocktail that contained indinavir. Because I and many other doctors stopped prescribing this medication a decade ago, I knew he had been keeping his condition from her for years. He stopped talking and avoided my gaze. It was clear he knew that I had learned his secret. I had many questions for him; but this visit was for her.

It was not the right moment to dredge up this history and ask how he could keep his diagnosis hidden while watching his partner struggle with her health. I chose not to ask about his dishonesty, their relationship and whether they had used condoms to protect her from getting HIV. At this point, I needed to help her understand that, even though she felt weak and sick, the medications would soon make her feel better. And that, with the right treatment, she could still live a long life.

While talking with my patient about her treatment, my mind kept wandering back to her partner’s secret. Was it my role to admonish him in front of her, or would that make things worse? What would they say to each other when they got home? I wanted to discuss these questions, but did I have a right to insert my judgment into this situation? At a private visit with me two weeks later, she let me know that this was the moment she realized he’d been keeping his diagnosis from her for years.

As a physician, I am not allowed to reveal any medical information about my patients or their circumstances without their written permission. This confidentiality is sacred. But in this case, that constraint felt inappropriate and irresponsible.

Unfortunately, this was not the first time I had seen an HIV diagnosis being kept secret in a serious monogamous relationship. Over the past four years, I have encountered dozens of HIV-positive patients, men and women, who have not told their sexual partners about their diagnosis. This is extremely troubling, especially considering that, in the United States, about 20 percent of people with HIV are unaware they are infected.

A few months ago, a patient of mine urgently wanted to know her viral load — which would tell her the amount of HIV in her bloodstream. She had a new boyfriend and had decided that if the amount of virus in her blood was low and was controlled by her medication, she would not disclose her status until they were married. For the first time, I realized that our incredible achievements in reducing HIV infections could be undermined by the fact that good treatment may make people feel less responsible for disclosing their status.

Am I somehow complicit in perpetuating the dishonesty if I say nothing?

I encouraged this patient to think about how she would feel if she were in her partner’s position. She did not feel strong enough to divulge her secret on her own and asked if she could bring him for a visit, so they could get tested together. That way, she reasoned, she could feign shock and distress when I revealed her diagnosis.

We played out the scenarios. What would happen if he learned that we both were being dishonest? Would physical harm come to her? Would I jeopardize my credibility and integrity as a physician? I certainly believe so.

This ethical dilemma looms large in medical practices across the country. Since we can’t destroy the sacred patient-provider confidentiality, we encourage patients to tell their partners about their HIV status and to use condoms, and we link them to support groups if we can. The next patient comes in, and the cycle repeats.

These issues give me heartburn. Most of my patients are very comfortable with me; they know they can tell me anything without being judged. But am I being a responsible medical professional by keeping someone’s health history confidential when I know that my patient might be putting someone else at risk? Should there be consequences for people who don’t tell their partners they have HIV? How do we balance personal responsibility while minimizing stigma and shame?

We cannot ignore these questions. We have conferences, research meetings and working-group discussions about prevention strategies, research agendas, and how to improve care and treatment. But in my experience, we don’t discuss, devise or implement ways to help patients be honest with their partners.

Above all, we need to remove the stigma associated with HIV testing and being HIV-positive. If health-care providers and patients viewed and handled the disease like the manageable and treatable condition it is, we could chip away at the negative perceptions associated with the virus, like we have done with cancer, tuberculosis and syphilis.

Changing perceptions of HIV, despite how it is transmitted, will eventually facilitate disclosure. Six years ago, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention recommended routine HIV screening in all medical settings. But in Washington, a city with one of the highest HIV/AIDS prevalence rates in the country, many health-care providers still think that they can discern which patients are at risk for HIV. If providers thought of the disease as a chronic condition similar to diabetes or high cholesterol, and tested for it regularly, HIV’s stigma would recede.

This seems simplistic because it is. Change would start with testing everyone at a certain age and continuing to do so routinely, whether or not they are “at risk” of infection.

A credible body such as the Institute of Medicine or a similar scientific group should convene a civil discussion about how and where to implement routine HIV screening in the primary-care setting. Officials should also reconsider HIPAA and other patient confidentiality regulations to determine when and if exceptions can be made.

If we want to eliminate the disease, we have to address the most difficult and unspoken parts of it. If we don’t, the achievements we’ve made in fighting HIV will plateau, and the epidemic will continue to grow.

Lisa Fitzpatrick, MD is a CDC-trained medical epidemiologist and infectious-diseases physician in Washington. From 2005 to 2007, she directed the CDC’s Global AIDS Program in the Caribbean and implemented the President’s Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief (PEPFAR) for that region. This piece originally appeared in The Washington Post on July 20, 2012.

Leave a Reply

38 Comments on "Should Doctors Keep Patients’ HIV Status a Secret?"


Guest
kate
Apr 24, 2015

I would just like to thank Prophet suleman for all his help and care during the time he cast a spell for me as a HIV Patient he was able to heal me from this disease ,,I highly recommend anyone to try him and believe in him
it truly honestly works,,Thank u so much for helping me in my time of need.. i will be recommending you to my friends and anyone who needs help in their lives Contact him through his email if you need his help (Prophetsuleman@gmail.com)

Guest
rose nelson
Jan 14, 2015

thank dr.daniel for his good work, I really believe HIV have cure I was HIV positive over since 1year before I come across a comment dr.daniel that he have cure any disease and virus but when I saw it i have it in mind that he can’t cure HIV I just decided to give a try I contact him that lucky night to meet him,and he said yes but I don’t believe him I think it was a scam or some thing like that but I still hold on to see the work of dr.daniel if he is saying the true he ask for different thing and some question about me I give him all the detail he needed and I wait to see his reply to my problem after all the thing is done he ask me to go for check up I went for hiv test I cant believe I was negative thanks dr.daniel for helping me, for not dying at this young age if you need help contact him now with this EMAIL and tell him your problem drdanielspelltemple02@gmail.com

Guest
Rachel
Dec 9, 2014

Interesting article. When I first read the title of, “Should Doctors Keep Patients’ HIV Status a Secret?”, my first reaction was no. However, after reading this article, I understand the ethical dilemmas that doctors are faced with and I think this doctor handled the situation appropriately.

Guest
Kelly Paul
Nov 18, 2014

I USED TO HAVE HIV, AND I WORK WITH THE U.S ARMY… I LOOKED FOR CURE
ALMOST ROUND THE WORLD, NOT UNTIL I CONTACTED DR OGBODU, I
NARRATED MY PREDICAMENT TO HIM, I WAS SHOCKED HE SAID ”NO CAUSE FOR
ALARM”’ HE SAID HE WILL NEED TO PREPARE THE MEDICATION FOR TWO DAYS, AFTER PREPARING IT, HE WILL SEND IT TO ME THROUGH COURIER SERVICE [DHL]. I RECEIVED IT AND I TOOK THE MEDICATION FOR TWO WEEKS AND THEN I WENT BACK TO THE HOSPITAL FOR MEDICAL CHECK UP…..MY FRIENDS YOU WON’T BELIEVE IT WAS NEGATIVE…. NOW I’M SOUND AND HEALTHY
STILL WORKING WITH THE U.S ARMY .
I BELIEVE HE CAN CURE ANY TYPE OF SICKNESS.
HIS EMAIL ADDRESS IS: [ogboduherbalhivcure@gmail.com] .
REGARD
KELLY

Guest
Diana Michael
Nov 18, 2014

I am out here to testify about the good work Dr Ogbodu has done in my life with his HIV herbal medication. I have been suffering from HIV disease for the past 3 years now before I came across Dr Ogbodu who healed me with his powerful HIV herbal medication. I never believe that Dr Ogbodu could ever get my HIV-AIDS cured with his herbal medication, i have tried almost everything but i could not find any solution to my disease, despite all these happening to me, i always spend alot to buy a HIV drugs from hospital and taking some several medications but no relief, until one day i was just browsing on the internet when i came across a great post of a lady who was testifying about how she get cured of her HIV disease with the help of Dr Ogbodu. So i have to contact him, and he ask me some few questions and he said a thing i will never forget that anyone who contact him is always getting his or her healing in just 2 weeks after taking his medication, so i did all the things only to see that at the very day which he said i will be healed, I regain all the strength that has left me before back and i became very strong and healthy, this disease almost end my life, so i went to the hospital to give the final test to the disease and the doctor said i am HIV negative, i am very happy and grateful to Dr Ogbodu about the healing he has given to me with his herbal medication. You can also email him for any kind of help via email ogboduherbalhivcure@gmail.com. Thank you once again Dr Ogbodu.

Guest
Nov 12, 2014

“Ghulam Ahmed Bilour has taken a principled stand,” agrees Ayesha Bibi, a housewife in the Pakistani capital. “The problem is that countries like the United States allow people like those who made the controversial film to hurt the feelings of Muslims. Why has the U.S. not prosecuted those who made the film?”

Guest
stacy Wıllıams
Nov 8, 2014

MY NAME IS STACY WILLIAMS FROM SOUTH USA.I SAW A COMMENT ON POSITIVE BLOGS AND I WILL LOVE TO TELL EVERY BODY HOW MY STATUS CHANGES TO NEGATIVE, AND AM NOW A LIVING WITNESS OF IT AND I THINK ITS A SHAME ON ME IF I DON’T SHARE THIS LOVELY STORY WITH OTHER PEOPLE INFECTED WITH THIS DEADLY VIRUS. HIV HAS BEEN ONGOING IN MY FAMILY, I LOST BOTH PARENTS TO HIV. AND IT IS SO MUCH PAIN I’VE NOT BEEN ABLE TO GET OVER.. AS WE ALL KNOW MEDICALLY THERE IS NO SOLUTION TO IT..AND MEDICATION IS VERY EXPENSIVE..SO SOMEONE INTRODUCED ME TO A HERBAL PRACTITIONER . I HAD A JOB THERE TO EXECUTE SO I TOOK TIME TO CHECK OUT ON HIM.I SHOWED HIM ALL MY TESTS AND RESULTS.. I WAS ALREADY DISORGANIZED WITH HIV AND IT WAS ALREADY TAKING ITS TOWL ON ME.. I HAD SPENT THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS SO I DECIDED TO TRY HIM OUT ALTHOUGH I DID’NT BELIEVE IN IT, I WAS JUST TRYING IT OUT OF FRUSTRATION? AND AFTER 2 DAYS, HE TOLD ME TO GO FOR A NEW TEST. AND YOU WON’T BELIEVE THAT 5 DIFFERENT DOCTORS CONFIRMED IT THAT AM NEGATIVE..IT WAS LIKE A DREAM,,I NEVER BELIEVE AIDS HAS CURE..AM NOW NEGATIVE,, AM A LIVING WITNESS..I DON’T KNOW HOW TO THANK THIS MAN? I JUST WANT TO HELP OTHERS IN ANY WAY I CAN.. I HAVE JOINED MANY FORUMS AND HAVE POSTED THIS TESTIMONIES AND ALOT OF PEOPLE HAS MAIL AND CALLED THIS MAN ON PHONE AND AFTER 2 DAYS THEY ALL CONFIRMED NEGATIVE.. BBC NEWS TOOK IT LIVE AND EVERY EVERYBODY SAW IT AND ITS NOW OUT IN PAPERS AND MAGAZINES THAT THERE IS A HERBAL CURE FOR HIV AND ALL WITH THE HELP OF THIS MAN,, IF YOU WISH TAKE IT OR NOT..GOD KNOWS HAVE TRIED MY BEST. ABOUT 28 PEOPLE HAVE BEEN CONFIRMED NEGATIVE THROUGH THE HERBAL CURE OF DR.SAKURA.. AND THEY SEND MAILS TO THANKS ME AFTER THEY HAVE BEEN CONFIRMED NEGATIVE,,THIS MAN IS REAL..DON’T MISS THIS CHANCE,,HIV IS A DEADLY VIRUS,,GET RID OF IT NOW.. If there is anyone who has similar problem and still looking for a way out, his email ıs dr.gabalaspelltemle@gmaıl.com

Guest

Thank you for any other useful website. The spot otherwise might just I get that type of real information designed in a very excellent usually means? I own a venture that i’m at the moment working in, and I have been on the look out and about pertaining to similarly info.

Guest
moureen solomon
Jul 10, 2014

He that work and never ask for anything thanks drosas for good work
for healing my brother for HIV sickness he was very sick for a year +
and my daddy have spend so much money on medical care and drug he have
being taking to some many place for healing… even different pastor
have pray for him it get worse every 6hous the man that heal with
45mins is here the man that the lord god have giving the power to put
every thing in place the man that give a word and never fail my kid
brother was just chatting one day when he see this post of jack about
the curing of HIV virus by drosas he run to my daddy and tell him
about the man my daddy decided to call him and confirm it if it is
true about the cure the man just assure him about his work that the
great power of is for father and his gods cure any disease include
HIV/AID, Ebola, Rota virus, Smallpox ,Hepatitis well we have hope on
him which we give a try to after five days my kind brother started
getting better as am write this comment his is at work now what a
miracle….. if you need help from drosas contact him now my friend
through his email or phone number drosassolutioncenter@gmail.Com call
+2349035428122

Guest
Onoja Eucharia
Jul 1, 2014

please i wish to know the implications of not reviling hiv test result to my a partner,husband or wife … what effect will these have in a family

Guest
Lisa
Mar 18, 2014

if you are free tomorrow at 1pm EST, join the conversation about this topic!

https://plus.google.com/u/0/events/c1e7dhf6r6brlsso27dae02p0t4#events/c1e7dhf6r6brlsso27dae02p0t4

Guest
Mar 8, 2014

Kelly,
Thanks to “condom size chart” above I am now seeing your comment. :). I believe a critical mass of providers should petition CDC and HRSA to consider these issues and provide national guidance. What do you think?

Guest

Hello my loved one! I want to say that this post is amazing, great written and include approximately all significant infos. I’d like to see more posts like this .

Guest
Kelly Adams
Jan 10, 2014

Great post, thank you Dr. Fitzpatrick for your thoughtfulness on this topic. I am a social worker in a busy public HIV clinic, and I find myself being extra cautious (in terms of privacy) in ways that I don’t think would apply if I worked, say, in a dialysis clinic. Clearly HIV is still highly stigmatized, but I wonder if health care professionals aren’t adding to the stigma by always “tiptoeing” around the issue? I mean, when a doctor feels the need to call me in to deliver positive test results because they’re THAT uncomfortable, I think there’s a problem.

This is a little tangential, but still relevant to the privacy vs. public health issues you’ve raised – considering the emphasis on retention in care and “treatment as prevention” in HIV positive patients, how far should we (social workers, doctors, etc) go in trying get bodies in the clinic? If you have a patient who is difficult to reach (phone being cut off, moving constantly, etc), how much can you reveal to a family member or partner in attempting to communicate that the patient NEEDS to be seen? Because HIV is an infectious disease, we can’t just give up and say “oh well” if a patient falls out of care (without viral suppression, they’re putting others at higher risk of infection), but I also think that people do have a right to some choice in the matter of receiving medical treatment…

Not easy questions!

Guest
Cassie Stegeman
Dec 9, 2013

Good post. Very controversial topic that needs more public awerness.