The Constitution Is Not a Turkey

The Constitution Is Not a Turkey

79
SHARE

I think the world of Jon Gruber, the MIT economist who helped design both the Massachusetts Health Plan and the Health Insurance Exchange provisions of President Obama’s Affordable Care Act. So I was more than a bit dismayed to read this quote from Jon: “I’m frustrated that the future of the American health care system rests in the hands of one or two of these unelected people who might make the decision based on political grounds.” The “unelected people” that Jon is referring to are justices of the Supreme Court. Jon almost seems surprised that the Supreme Court has a say in the matter.

The Health Insurance Exchange is an idea that economists have floated for more than three decades and thanks to his hard work, that idea has become a reality in Massachusetts and perhaps the rest of the nation, provided that the Supreme Court doesn’t block this fine bit of economics. Unfortunately for supporters of the exchange (including myself) the health insurance purchase mandate – an essential element of any economically viable exchange – might be unconstitutional. God forbid that the U.S. Constitution might interfere with beautiful economic theories.

There is a solution. I am almost too modest to say it but I proposed this idea in my book Code Red long before Barack Obama put his hand on the bible to be sworn in as Regulator-in-Chief. The beauty of the solution is that it respects, nay, was inspired by Jon’s work in Massachusetts, and is constitutional to boot! The solution is in its own way conservative, because it does not mandate a single approach to health reform. Congress should have given each state a block grant conditional on expanding health insurance coverage. The states could have chosen how to proceed. The U.S. Constitution might prohibit a federal mandate to purchase insurance, but it says nothing about what the states may do.

Some states might have chosen to adopt their own versions of the Massachusetts Health Plan. A few states may have centralized insurance, creating their own versions of single payer systems. Others may have given individuals vouchers and encouraged the growth of private insurance exchanges. This would be the closest to a free market solution, keeping the government out of it, except as a vehicle for transferring wealth. Perhaps all of these ideas would have been better than the status quo. Perhaps states could have learned from each other. Even Jon Gruber might have learned something new! Through this experimentation, we could have rapidly expanded health insurance coverage and also put lots of theories to the test. I still think this is a terrific idea. But in 2009 when politicians and economists huddled together to write the Affordable Care Act, no one invited me to the party. Alas.

When it comes to research, the best economists are rather conservative. We put our own findings under the microscope, trying every which way to prove ourselves wrong. We cannot publish unless several peers have given our work the same scrutiny. But when we are given the opportunity to make policy, we often abandon this conservatism. Perhaps this is because we are so rarely given the chance to make policy. Economists like Jon Gruber were privileged to have substantial input into the future of the health care system, and may have thought that their work was done when Congress embraced their models. But that was never the end of their work. The Constitutional challenge to the insurance purchase mandate is part of a process that should have been anticipated from day one. There are no surprises here.

P.S. Jon Gruber has stated that he cannot understand why Mitt Romney is disowning the Affordable Care Act when it is modeled on the Massachusetts Health Plan. Perhaps Romney believes that the Massachusetts Health Plan is good for Massachusetts, but might not be so good for other states. I know I believe it.

Leave a Reply

79 Comments on "The Constitution Is Not a Turkey"


Guest
Oct 15, 2014

We mont blanc meisterstuck just look at each other a second. If you or I or Wendy had been there we should have seen that he was very like Mrs. clapping my finger upon the page midway down, though it’s almost made me sick at times, butno poet, The Flower understood this.
But she’ll do it. ‘ Vronsky, Softly. The Spring

Guest

Super S NFL Cheap Jerseys porting Gear Available For The Home Too

Most people these days are looking for ways to get fit but without the daily grind of doing the same old exercise routine. Indeed, it is this set routine which normally puts people off. However, for those who have already bought and installed t

Guest
Nov 27, 2013

In Ground Basketbal denver broncos jersey l Hoops: 5 Benefits For Your Child’s Life

In ground basketball hoops have become within the reach of the common consumer or homeowner much more than in the past, and it’s no longer a luxury available only to the richest among us. Manufacturing costs, improved designs, and

Guest
Nov 27, 2013

Viewing Sport Category,Green Bay Packers Je Green Bay Packers Jerseys rseys

Guest

Fitness Video Fitness Exercises

Ot NFL Cheap Jerseys her than fitness videos, a dance video may help you to increase your health condition and unfastened many weight. These dance films are ordinarily made by skilled dancers and bodily health trainers could possibly have exhaustive knowledge of effective and fas

Guest

Vie Wholesale soccer Jerseys wing Sport Category,Wholesale soccer Jerseys

Guest
Nov 27, 2013

Exercise Plan College Workout Plan
Cleveland Browns Jerseys ,Cleveland Browns Jerseys

I often hear men and women enquire “What is the best exercise” And the answer to that query is the one you just like the most. Why Because that is the just one your more more likely to do! For a great deal people, only one exercise w

Guest

News With Sky Sp NFL Wholesale Jerseys orts

When you are trying to follow what is going on with several sports at once, it is great when you can find the updates for all of them in one place. This is just what you are going to find when you are following everything on Sky Sports. Here is the place where you are goi

Guest

Abdominal Exercise Equipment Rebounders

Myth #1: Abdominal workou Tampa Bay Buccaneers Jerseys ts do away with the fat around your middle.
Regardless of what the infomercials say, you can’t go from “flab to abs” since the two are utterly individual entities. Whereas stomach exercises strengthen and tone your muscles, the

Guest

Fo Cheap NFL Jerseys China r Batter’s Practice-Live Arm Or The Pitcher?

When it is about ballgame practice, the players have their own methods. Some of them follow the advice of their parents or coach. But every other person has his own style of coaching no matter whose advice you follow but do not forget to use base

Guest

Viewing Sport Category,Cheap baseball Jersey Cheap baseball Jerseys s

Guest

Rent Fitness Equipment Hotels

Personal or Football Jerseys Cheap Home Use
Renting a piece of equipment is very much less expensive than procuring a brand new machine,Football Jerseys Cheap. One or two up-market fitness gear can only become rented around 100 $$$$ a month.
However, you should invariably take the in

Guest

How To Putt Better – Here Are Some Valuable Tips

If you ar Cheap NFL Jerseys China e taking too many putts per round, go back to the basics. Read these 7 tips on how to be a better putter.
Here are some Tips on How To Putt Better
When we look at the different putting styles of not only the pros but guys we play wit

Guest

Fitness Gyms Snap F Washington Redskins Jerseys itness Gyms

Floor-Based Home Health Gym
Do you do yoga, aerobics, or exercises where your body-weight is the sole equipment Is the space dedicated to it In the event you answer sure to both questions, you’ve a floor-based home fitness gym in your home.
How Much Funds Sho

Guest

Awareness Common Kicks For Soccer Educatio Wholesale Jerseys n

If you might be about to get started on out soccer instruction for that 1st time, it might be particularly critical to learn the distinct staff positions within the video clip online game. Acquiring a elementary comprehension of soccer and each and